Oscar Manuel Perez
2010-09-10 17:04:26 UTC
Wrong, wrong, and wrong.
This is most definitely a Logical Fallacy.
This is an error of reasoning.
God by definition is the eternal spirit or human or both. He is God and cannot be limited to it's definition. Meaning he is more profound than we can to put into words. We may distinguish him from other beings but cannot truly classify him in such words.
The universe can be defined, and can be limited to laws of physics. It also most definitely has a beginning, cause it has an age.
For this reason alone it is a reasoning mistake or error.
God can be anything he wants to. That is one of the abilities a God has. God is the eternal spirit that is immaterial. Meaning immaterial is like space that is out there, it exist (that is why we call it space) and this space does not need a creator because it is immaterial and such immaterial things are not made of matter, bones, or energy. In other words, they are intangible things. As intangible things you cannot touch nor you cannot create because you don't need to create nothing. Nothing exist like space and does not need to be created because it is nothing. The only thing that does not need create is nothing. If you don't follow this logic than you are no more smarter than a roach.
God is this immaterial thing that is intangible and not need created like space.
Vs
The universe in which is potential energy, matter, and the invisible space. All this things can be detected, can be measure, and can be seen. Energy can be detected, space can be measure from point a to point b, and matter can be seen. Material things like cars, diamonds, the Earth, the Sun, are all matter or energy. They exist in the material world. I can build a paper airplane, I can make a fire from a match. All this things can be made. In exchange for God. Sorry you cannot. For you people to understand this, I must brake it to you softly cause it will hurt you. You exist because your material parents made you. So you are a non-godly entity or human. Would you have needed parents if you were not born?
If you say no, you are a logical mortal human (Material entity). Born humans or material that need to be created.
Now forward this question to God?
If God says no, then he is the unborn God (Immaterial entity) that is a logical God. Unborn or immaterial need not be created.
THIS IS THE LOGICAL FALLACY. The fallacy in which is incorrect reasoning is that an unborn God needs a parent or creator, Why does he need a parent if he is unborn?, immaterial things are intangible, and unborn or uncreated. Material things need to be created because they are not immaterial, space, or nothing. You cannot say material things doesn't need to be created because they are not space and are matter. Fallacy i repeat again. It's like saying, I can create nothing. It's a Fallacy, how can you create nothing whe you are doing something. I am human born child, I do not need a parent. The only way you can say that is when you are unborn. That is why God says you are my off-springs, because through him we exist from an unborn perspective and live here in the material world, in the flesh.
Also, I want to state that it is logical to talk about immaterial. In math and in human life understanding's it exist. I math there are negative numbers which are:
Further explanation
An integer is a "whole number." It has no fractional part to it. A negative integer is simply an integer less than 0. A positive integer, on the other hand, is an integer greater than 0. Technically, 0 is neither positive nor negative.
Therefore anything less than zero or less than nothing is immaterial. It exist. In everyday life people owe you money, this quantity of money owed you may say it's immaterial. You don't have it but you know the money that is owed does exist in your mind until you recieve it.