Question:
why do christians celebrate christmas?
?
2009-12-15 14:55:20 UTC
If christians believe christmas is a religous holiday, why did they adopt a lot of the pagan rituals to go along with it? Christmas trees were derived from the yule log. The idea of santa and presents came from the danes. christians just churched it up, to make it a celebration of christ's birth. When we all know jesus of nazerene,was not born in the winter but spring.
24 answers:
Elijah
2009-12-15 15:07:54 UTC
Another way of asking this is, "Why are true Christians considered odd for NOT celebrating Christmas?



Christmas - It's Origins And Associations

http://searchforbibletruths.blogspot.com/2009/12/christmas-how-should-christian-view-it.html
greenshootuk
2009-12-17 11:34:15 UTC
They did not adopt a lot of pagan rituals. They adopted none, as far as the historical evidence goes.



Christmas tree - no evidence of this at all in any pagan society. Christ was known to early Christian writers as the new Tree of Life, the original being in the Garden of Eden. The glass baubles represent the fruit of the tree.



Yule log - No evidence of this from pre-Christian religions either. Not mentioned in any of the old Viking or Germanic sagas.



Santa Claus - Derived from Saint Nicholas, a Christian bishop known for his secret gift giving.



Jesus' actual birthday - Simply not known. There is nothing in the bible from which you can deduce it. December 25th is just as likely as any other day. However, it is the day the church chose to celebrate His birth 1700 years ago.
Me.
2009-12-15 15:09:14 UTC
Christmas trees are actually a cross between two trees that German Christians bred. Not a log. The idea of Santa came from a 3rd century saint by the name of Saint Nicholas who loved children and gave all of his money every year to give children gifts in the name of Christ. Christmas is the day Christians chose to celebrate the birth of Christ.
Max50
2009-12-15 15:23:34 UTC
I am celebrating the birth of the Messiah as far as the date goes it doesn't matter to me.

As for the pagan symbols you are referring to they were used to apply a different meaning.

To me the tree I have up is not about whatever it is a symbol in my home to remember those Christmases of the past and ornaments each a story to remind me of my family members that are alive and those who are long gone. A tree of remembrance.



You question lacks originality because every year someone comes along and rehash the same old story.



1) Christmas is too commercialized

2) We need to get back to the Original meaning

3) People like you bring come up with the some question about the pagan roots of the parts of symbols Christians use.



Each I can't do anything about them but to work on myself and try to get closer to G-d.



So this season I wish you a Happy Hanukkah (a celebration that Yeshua himself celebrated)

and Merry Christmas as I remember the birth of our Savior.



Yours too if you want just ask him.
Kenponders
2009-12-15 15:08:21 UTC
Because it is (or was) a pagan festival. As the other guy says it actually celebrates the winter solstice. It's a mismatch because we didn't get the calendar accurate until fairly recently. When the Catholic church was made the state religion by Constantine back in three hundred and something at the council of Nicea, the church needed help converting all the non-Christians. It did so by transposing Christian festivals for the pagan ones. Since no one knows when Christ was born and it was the major pagan festival they used that.

They also moved the sabbath from Saturday for the same reason.
goodluckwithhat
2009-12-15 15:02:21 UTC
Oh yes. The "pagan" rituals. I expected it from the question.



Did it ever occur to you and the countless others who ask the same question twice a year--Easter gets the same question--that early Christian leaders used celebrated pagan holidays to relate to Christianity to help the pagans understand better? It's a classic teaching technique to use what the students knows in helping him/her understand the new concept. Thus, Christians were helping pagans understand Jesus, his birth, his divinity, etc. by linking it to pagan celebrations. Therefore, what was once pagan has become Christian. Once the pagan's were converted, they continued to celebrate their holidays but with a Christian connection. It's really not that difficult to understand.



And, indeed, Santa Claus comes from Saint Nicholas, the bishop of Myra in Turkey. He had a reputation of putting coins in the shoes of those who left them outside their doors. Now, tell me you can't see the connection between the two?
gossamer presents... Sarah!
2009-12-15 15:07:01 UTC
Why do you care and/or want to celebrate Christian holidays?



Is it a coincidence that American atheists only celebrate Christmas, Valentine's Day, Easter, oh, only Christian-centric holidays! The reality is atheist love Christian holidays and want to find ways to rationalize for why their doing it, so they accentuate the "pagan origins" theory and run wild with it.



Some atheists are so brave when they stand up to Christians and against Christian holidays, and we all know these same empty suits would never stand up to other religion's holidays, 'cause if they did they'd hog-tied and ripped to pieces. It's a joke.
Dave & Donna
2009-12-15 15:12:25 UTC
As you say,to celebrate the birth of our Lord and savior Jesus Christ.However,so that you might know.A lot of the Christian celebrations do coincide with pagan rites.For example All Saints Day(Halloween)and as you've mentioned,some of the Christmas celebration has been influenced by the European traditions.Chris Kringle,Santa etc.But note the spirit of giving is strongly stressed and is a parallel to Jesus giving His life for us,the giving of gifts by the Magi and on & on.So merry Christmas to you brother.Thanks for asking.
Millie
2009-12-15 15:16:41 UTC
So you really think that God, who is wise and powerful enough to see what's in our hearts and mind, will actually believe that we are celebrating some pagan festivals??? HE is wiser than that and no matter what the origin of the celebration was, HE knows that we don't and have never belonged to those pagan beliefs.



But, of course, only a true believer is able to trust in God's discernment.
anonymous
2009-12-15 15:00:12 UTC
they do both the toys and to celebrate the birth of the savior Christ Jesus, Christmas was put on that day by Christians because it was a pagan holiday and wanted to over shadow it.
anonymous
2009-12-15 15:23:44 UTC
For your information, the original of "Santa" was St Nicholas, who was not exactly known for being a pagan.
anonymous
2009-12-15 15:00:09 UTC
Santa was derived from Saint Nicholas.



Please stop the insanity. It's just a celebration get over it
Tammy D
2009-12-15 15:05:48 UTC
because it is on this day we celebrate the birth of christ
AutumnWynd777
2009-12-15 14:59:44 UTC
Because Yeshua/Jesus Is The Reason For The Season.
anonymous
2009-12-15 14:58:46 UTC
Thank you. Hail Odin and merry Yule
The Codfather
2009-12-15 15:01:08 UTC
Because its a day to celebrate the Annual airing of The Wizard of Oz and Zulu of course!
A DRAGON
2009-12-15 14:59:14 UTC
At this point it is mindless habit.

But, no problem, it's the same reason the rest of us celebrate it.
NewlyBorn
2009-12-15 15:01:15 UTC
The story of the Grinch stealing Christmas repeats itself... spiritually speaking, of course!
Blackacre
2009-12-15 14:58:58 UTC
They like to remember the solstice?



Sten (above): you might want to research the history of Christmas. It has little to do with dead Jewish carpenters.
iā™„pandas
2009-12-15 15:02:09 UTC
why do atheists celebrate christmas?

http://www.essortment.com/all/christmaspagan_rece.htm



and santa was derived from st. nicholas , who is catholic (christian)
moses rep
2009-12-15 15:03:06 UTC
Persons who have turned their life over to God have repented( turn from sin) Any involvement in idols ect is sin cut & dry. They are not celbrating for God!
The Not-So-Loved Apostle Paul
2009-12-15 15:03:31 UTC
WOW!!! THIS QUESTION HAS NEVER EVER BEEN ASKED HERE!!!



Oh, sorry...... here's YOUR sign.....
Sir
2009-12-15 14:58:37 UTC
Becuase of the birth of Christ, not toys.
anonymous
2009-12-15 14:58:54 UTC
Where'd you read that, some Atheist propaganda website?


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...