Question:
In Your Opinion, What Is the Most Tragic Story in the Bible?
sugnim
2010-06-17 09:25:47 UTC
Out of all of the stories in the Bible, which one do you think is the most tragic?

If you believe that the Bible was written or inspired by God, why do you think this story was included in the Bible? Even if you believe that the story is historically accurate--why this story out of all of the other stories in humanity?

If you believe that the Bible is a collection of stories written & collected by humans, but not inspired by any god, why do you think this story might have been included?

Thanks for your thoughts!
25 answers:
Ridney
2010-06-17 09:32:28 UTC
For me, the book of Job.

I once tried to read through the Bible, cover to cover, but stopped there. The whole concept of it upset and angered me. Job didn't deserved to be used as a pawn :(.

I realized after reading it that I was angry at God, and felt what he did was despicable. As a Christian, I'm not really supposed to be worthy of questioning my god, so I figured either my feelings or my faith had to change.

I couldn't change my feelings so..That story shapes my beliefs today. Also, it didn't make me think too highly of organized religion.
kevin
2016-06-04 03:54:37 UTC
1) Always had doubt, but mainly just ignored it, until I couldn't ignore it anymore. I cannot say that it wasn't because of tragedy because there were several deaths that occurred while I was in high school (although none of any direct family members or friends--just people that I knew at school). However, considering I didn't accept my atheism until much later (in my early 20s), I don't know that this had an effect. I will say that death as a Christian was far scarier than death as an atheist. 2) yes, their dead, they suffer no longer (also they never experience joy). 3) I don't think religion is "ignorant" per se. Mainly I find religion to be intellectually dishonest. Basically, most religious people are just as normal as every other atheist, except when you mention God they throw up a brick wall where all of a sudden all logic and reasoning goes out the window. 4) Yes and no. Yes it's a waste because it's fake, but if believing in Santa Claus makes your Christmas better, then why not? Now, there are many reasons for why not, but that's not what you asked. 5) Most Christians' main defense is the Bible. Yet you here just admitted that the Bible is ridiculous--I agree, it's ridiculous so it's no proof of anything. Why is it God's word when he says, a man who denies god is a fool but it's not God's word when he says that all animals got on an ark that was smaller than the Titanic?? 6) If god is all powerful, then he should be more powerful than the devil. The devil is only allowed to do what God allows, so anything the devil does is directly allowed/sanctioned by God (if he exists, which he doesn't). 7) They have TV series dedicated to ghosts and yet no one has ever produced any convincing evidence. So I don't know where you get the idea that there is a lot of evidence? There is none. 8) Then either he's a bastard and I never had any hope to begin with or he doesn't care if you believe in him or not.
?
2010-06-17 09:28:39 UTC
Well I think the most tragic is the stories of King Solomon. I do not read the bible as my religion as I believe in The Great Spirit and follow Native American Spirituality, however I study religion and think that all of the stories of King Solomon are tragic and heart wrenching because there are so many decisions that must be made about each other, and in the end, every decision will have a horrid consequence
Beetjie
2010-06-17 13:14:17 UTC
The story of the rich man that died and went to hell and Lazarus that died and went to heaven.



27 And [the man] said, Then, father, I beseech you to send him to my father's house--



28 For I have five brothers--so that he may give [solemn] testimony and warn them, lest they too come into this place of torment.



29 But Abraham said, They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear and listen to them.



30 But he answered, No, father Abraham, but if someone from the dead goes to them, they will repent (change their minds for the better and heartily amend their ways, with abhorrence of their past sins).



31 He said to him, If they do not hear and listen to Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be persuaded and convinced and believe [even] if someone should rise from the dead. Luke 16:27 - 31.



The reason that I find this the most tragic is that 2000 years later this is still happening. Souls are still lost because people refuse to believe and only realize it when they cannot be saved anymore and cannot warn any of their family or friends.
rebornbethy
2010-06-17 09:32:45 UTC
In my opinion, from a christian point-of-view, I believe Judas betraying Jesus was pretty tragic, though it was necessary. This particular story was written in the Bible for our knowledge and understanding.
imrod
2010-06-17 09:29:03 UTC
The story of King Agrippa as told in the King James Version



Agrippa said unto Paul, Almost thou persuadest me to be a Christian. (Act. 26:28).



He came so close. So very sad.
mrglass08
2010-06-17 09:36:42 UTC
The Fall of Adam, he knew exactly what he was doing but decided to sin against God anyway and upon sinning he realized exactly how much he actually lost.
no1home2day
2010-06-17 09:29:29 UTC
When Adam, who had walked with God, who had heard His voice, and who had received direct instructions from God, turned around and disobeyed Him and trusted the voice of the stranger rather than the voice of his own Creator.



I believe this is literal, as there is no logical way to make this into an analogy or parable or symbolic.



It was the fall of Mankind into slavery to satan; and the beginning of sin in the world, which is why God had to come to earth as Jesus Christ, the Son of God; and it was the introduction of death into this world.
anonymous
2010-06-17 09:28:38 UTC
Noah's Ark seems most tragic to me. It just is horrible to think how bad the people must have become if God decided to wipe them all out. It's incredible how he chose Noah and his family to collect all of those animals. I couldn't even imagine it.
Beardog
2010-06-17 09:27:48 UTC
Sampson and Delilah. Setting aside the super-hero aspects of the story, look at all the grief that guy went through for love. She betrayed his trust on three separate occasions, until his eyes were gouged out with hot pokers, and he still loved her.



That or Job, who was a good guy that was put through hell to settle a bet between God and the Devil. His wife and children died, his friends left him, he lost everything he owned, was stricken with illness... all just to see how much he could take.
Everybody Can Can!
2010-06-17 09:28:57 UTC
Probably the death of Jesus.

God told certain people to write the Bible. In the book of Revilation, it shows how He asked John to write it.
yesmar
2010-06-17 09:30:21 UTC
The most tragic tale in my opinion is that of Adam and Eve. Although it is poetry, it contains the truth of the human race, and set the stage for all the tragedy that follows. Thanks for asking friend.
⌡Machine Head⌠
2010-06-17 09:29:50 UTC
The Abomination at Gibeah, the most appalling story ever told.

Sadly that fits all the criteria for being a true story.
Apollo Gist
2010-06-17 10:28:52 UTC
Tragic..hmm, there are one or two that would pop into my mind, but, personally, I would have to go with the Flood. The entire population of the earth, wiped out except for the few in the ark. Not to mention the original earth being destroyed as well... this would have to be the most tragic story accounted in the Bible.



I personally believe the Bible is inspired by God, so I will be answering the questions you addressed to the Christians. Before one can actually can actually answer these questions however, We need to understand, to some small degree, God and also understand, completely, the story of Creation.



Let's start with creation, shall we? As you read the list of things God created, you will run into an odd, and seaming illogical creation step. In verse six of Genesis, you will see God taking the murky mass that is earth, and separating the waters into two sections. An outer section of water, which he calls sky, a gap within this outer layer of water, then a smaller ball of water within.

As you continue, you will notice that the rest of creation deals only with the inner section of water in that complex orb. What the book of Genesis is suggesting here is that, at the very beginning, there was a layer of water in the earth's atmosphere. An "aquasphere" if you will.



Now, the story of the flood in not that of a continuous rain that flooded the earth, but rather a story of this "aquasphere" having a hole punched in whatever forces were holding it up, and pouring down upon the earth with incredible force.



This leads me to one of my answers to your first question.

I believe this story was included, in part, to show the authenticity of the Bible as a historical record.



As is evidence of this blast of water hitting the earth and eventually covering it, we have what are known as "fossil graveyards".

These fossil graveyards contain the bones of mammoths, elephants, lions, tigers, saber tooth tigers, cats, dogs, birds, dinosaurs, fish, AND MAN all strewn and entangled together as result of the water sweeping them to a single place, or crushing them in place.

Not do we only have this, but also the affect water slamming into earth which would have also caused tremendous amounts of earthquakes worldwide. We can see that at one time, the earth was a Pangaea. This is not only seen from the two sides of the continents, but also from the undersea mountains which record where the separations took place.





Now, secondly, we must understand God's reason for wiping out the vast majority of his creation.

After Adam and Eve betrayed God in an attempt to become gods themselves, the door was opened for mankind to either worship God, or themselves. When we walk into the story of the flood, we have jumped hundreds, or perhaps even thousands of years, after the story of creation. The earth is well populated.

The thing about this story, is that every single man on the face of the earth had forsaken God. All they desired was to please themselves in any matter they deemed fit. The Bible accounts them being virtually incapable of thinking of anything other than evil.

To see His most loved creation, which was created to love and be loved, reduced to hatred and the love of all that is evil, God was in a state of absolute sorrow. The Bible states that he even "regretted" creating us.

God noted that there was only one family on the face of the earth that still loved him, and as such, he decided to save Noah's family and start over. The wages of sin was death, and since the people practically worshiped sin, the consequence was carried out.



Now for my other answer to that question,

I believe this story was placed in the Bible, to show a bit of God's character. His immeasurable Love and Mercy, but also his unwavering Justice.

The fact of the matter is, the people did not forsake god in a moment. It was a slow, gradual fade. It wasn't until there wasn't the slightest ounce of either love or good within the hearts of the people that God carried out the punishment.

Further, he SAVED Noah and his family. There is NO WAY that these people were living in a completely fallen society and remained completely pure themselves. It is obvious, upon thought, that these people were also sinners with the rest of the earth, however, they were the only ones left that loved God and at least tried to serve Him.







I could ramble on and on and on FOREVER on this story and other things it brings up, but Yahoo has actuaelly forbidden the length of this answer. lol

NOW, I must admit, I am thoroughly confused as to what it is you are asking in that second question. Could you perhaps re-word it so that I can accurately answer it?
?
2010-06-17 09:28:27 UTC
The most tragic is of course that God became a man, and man treated Him like crap and tortured and killed Him.



But ultimately that broke the punishment of death over us.
anonymous
2010-06-17 09:33:01 UTC
2 Kings 6:26-29



As the king of Israel was passing by on the wall, a woman cried to him, "Help me, my lord the king!"



The king replied, "If the Lord does not help you, where can I get help for you? From the threshing floor? From the winepress?" Then he asked her, "What's the matter?"



She answered, "This woman said to me, 'Give up your son so we may eat him today, and tomorrow we'll eat my son.' So we cooked my son and ate him. The next day I said to her, 'Give up your son so we may eat him,' but she had hidden him."
Clark Kent
2010-06-17 09:29:38 UTC
the bible is a second edition of the judaism, one of the tragic stories is the flood that killed million by the so-called god whom is full of love.
anonymous
2010-06-18 10:50:17 UTC
The whole thing.
pantomime win a ham contest
2010-06-17 09:37:32 UTC
the book of uranus
sooperj
2010-06-17 09:27:48 UTC
Jesus died to remove original sin, which never happened as adam and eve didn't exist. Sucks to be gods kid.



I find the fact that people believe it tragic.
anonymous
2010-06-17 09:27:17 UTC
The story where that guy called Jesus was born
William
2010-06-17 09:27:09 UTC
None of the Biblical characters are sufficiently noble to be "tragic" in any way.
Anon
2010-06-17 09:28:33 UTC
maybe uriah that is so sad.



or maybe Mephibosheth
?
2010-06-17 09:26:36 UTC
the making of the bible.
anonymous
2010-06-17 09:27:27 UTC
the death of the firstborn sons when the king wanted to kill them all BUT JESUS EsCAPED WITH his parents.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...