Question:
Can you dispute the fact that science has it roots and beginnings in religion and spirituality?
anonymous
2009-08-13 17:23:01 UTC
Naturally one may not want to admit it, but historically it is true. If you don't think so, express yourself.
Fifteen answers:
?
2009-08-15 21:21:39 UTC
Science definitely has its roots in spirituality but not in religion. Why! Spirituality forms the base of life... the essence of life! It is the presence of a soul atman... the spirit within our human body that makes the human journey worthwhile.



Spiritually it is our soul atman... the spirit within that is on its cosmic journey of 8.4 million manifestations... an earthly life cycle of 96.4 million years! Our soul atman... the spirit within manifests the human form to work out its karma... remove the dross impurities within!



Spirituality is the path through which one finally reaches God. One can never reach God Almighty through path of religion. For reaching the stage of enlightenment (kaivalya jnana) and finally salvation (moksha) traveling path of spirituality is necessitated.



Both science and religion were meant for ephemeral phase of life... the average life span of 70 to 80 years in the life of human beings! To live life in a meaningful manner... religion is necessitated. It keeps the whole flock of human beings together... bonded!



Science is necessitated to keep the evolution moving ahead. In absence of science... the whole purpose of creation gets negated... everything in the cosmic system would become monotonous... finally decay and die!



It is the presence of a spirit within us as our soul atman... that makes life enjoyable... worth living! It is traveling the path of spirituality Mahavira, Gautama Buddha, Jesus Christ or Prophet Mohammed finally gained enlightenment in their lifetime! More on spirituality- http://www.godrealized.org/Spirituality.html
Patricia
2009-08-13 17:59:05 UTC
I believe that mythology specifically played the biggest role in the roots and beginnings of science, and not so much religion and spirtuality. Some would say though, that mythology, religion and spirituality are one and the same. Myths came about because people had questions about the environment around them, so they began to ask: Why do the seasons change? Why is there day and night? How was the world created? Every culture has it's own answers though they are similar in many ways. The answers are in the myths, and from these myths which spoke of beings with powers and a world full of magic, it became religion. With the advancements of technology and science though, it was shown that the sun did not rise because of Apollo, and thunder is not caused by Zeus' lightening bolts. Science is because we have to know, we want to know, it is human nature.
Leo
2009-08-13 17:30:06 UTC
Religion has its roots in science and philosophy.



You make a statement similar to;



"The Pyramids are famous because of the Egyptians"



Whereas the truth is actually;



"The Egyptians are famous because of the Pyramids"



Two similar subjects yet two entirely different statements.



Jamie - Long, science is merely the study of nature to further understanding. Our ancestors studied nature and discovered how to use tools, from that we developed. Also 3000 years is a little short, in fact extremely short.



I would say Religion has spanned from the unexplained, that which has been observed yet not understood. It is trying to bridge together the pieces of science we have yet to develop.



Science begins with observation and ends with an analysis. Thus;

- Ancient ancestor observes that nuts have a hard shell

- Recognises, by most likely chance as with many scientific discoveries, that rock is harder than the nut shell

- Begins smashing nut on the rock, works but not very efficiently

- One of his friends sees this and observes. He/she then takes a smaller rock and smashes the nut. Success!!

- Others now see that the rock can be used for food, we now have one of our first tools



If you are a believer in evolution you would have to say that science predates religion. If you are religious then will have to say science stems from religion because Adam and Eve, the beginnings of mankind, knew of spirituality from the beginning.
Weise Ente
2009-08-13 17:36:56 UTC
Nope. Sorry, but you are quite mistaken.



Modern science stems from the Age of Enlightenment, the period when people started to break off the shackles of religious dogma.



Edit:

Actually science is quite far removed from Greek philosophy (which also flourished when they stopped caring about their gods as much).



The Greek idea was to sit around and think about the way the world works from looking at it. Aristotle surmised heavier objects fall faster.



In science you actually test your ideas. Galileo demonstrated that all objects fall at the same speed.



You should read up on the history of science.



Edit: It came from reason, not religion. The rejection of the entire concept of faith.



You really have no idea what soever about what science is or where it comes from. Go get an education.
jenelle
2016-09-11 13:54:43 UTC
Science has many questions, many solutions — hundreds of thousands. Religion has just one reply; whatever the query the reply stays the identical. Buddha used to mention: You style sea water from wherever, the style stays the identical, the saltiness of it. Whatsoever you ask is fairly inappropriate. I will reply the identical considering that I have bought just one reply. But that one reply is sort of a grasp key; it opens all doorways. It isn't involved with any specific lock — any lock and the important thing opens it. Religion has just one reply and that reply is meditation. And meditation manner tips on how to empty your self. Spirituality is all approximately one's man or woman travel to the Light inside. Whereas faith is guy-made, spirituality frames the system of private progress, religion, wish, knowledge, and transformation. Religion manner the circumference, and spirituality manner the middle. Religion has some thing of spirituality, however simplest some thing - a indistinct radiation, some thing like a mirrored image within the lake of the starry night time, of the whole moon. Spirituality is the truly factor, faith is only a derivative. And one of the crucial finest misfortunes that has occurred to humanity is that persons are being advised to be devout no longer religious. Hence they begin redecorating their circumference, they domesticate person. Character is your circumference. By portray your circumference, the middle isn't converted. But if you happen to difference the middle, the circumference routinely is going by way of a change. Science is expertise. Religion isn't expertise. Religion is love. The phrase ‘faith’ comes from a root this means that binding in combination — falling into love, fitting one. Science grows out of doubt. Religion grows out of marvel. Between the 2 is philosophy; it has no longer but made up our minds — it is going on putting among doubt and sweetness. Sometimes the thinker doubts and regularly the thinker wonders: he's simply in among. If he doubts an excessive amount of, through and through he turns into a scientist. If he wonders an excessive amount of, through and through he turns into devout. If you emerge as too sceptical, you emerge as scientists. If you emerge as too childlike, you emerge as devout. Science exists with doubt. Religion exists with marvel. If you wish to be devout then create extra marvel, detect extra marvel. Allow your eyes to be extra stuffed with marvel than some thing else. Be amazed through the whole lot that's going down. Everything is so drastically uncommon that it's easily implausible the way you move on residing with out dancing, the way you move on residing with out fitting ecstatic. You have got to no longer be seeing what is going on throughout. Spirituality belongs in your principal being, and faith simplest to the outermost movements, behaviour, morality. Religion is formal, going to the church each Sunday is a social affair. Science involves atomic materiality and faith involves cosmic realization. Science actions downwards to the final, lowest denominator and faith actions upwards to the maximum denominator. They transfer in reverse dimensions. So technology transforms the whole lot right into a situation, considering that if you happen to need to take on it scientifically, you first need to make a decision whether or not this can be a situation or no longer. Religion takes thriller as the bottom. There is not any situation, lifestyles isn't a situation. The emphasis is that it are not able to be solved. A situation manner some thing solvable, some thing which will also be recognized, some thing knowable. It will not be recognized proper now, however it's not unknowable. At essentially the most it can be unknown, however that unknownness will disappear and it'll be modified right into a recognized factor. God Bless
Zombie
2009-08-13 17:30:27 UTC
Actually, science has roots in natural philosophy, which may or may not be rooted in religion, depending on what you're talking about. That aside, it doesn't really matter, since human thought progresses by replacing old ideas with better ones.
?
2009-08-13 17:34:26 UTC
Of course it does. Science comes from philosophy, philosophy is intimately concerned with theology.



Consider Pythagoras, who blended some rather insane mysticism with some extraordinary mathematical accomplishments.



I'm not sure what point you're trying to prove though - most people with a reasonable knowledge of history would know this.
anonymous
2009-08-13 18:59:34 UTC
Of course , like astrology , was the only source and instrumentation for directions , seasons , and weather explanation broadcast , astrology is useless today but religion is still a social and culture tool of Communication today ; spirituality for ever as long as mankind survive .......
numbnuts222
2009-08-13 17:32:40 UTC
Yes, the early astronomers were priests, they used to have to have accurate methods of calculating the day so they could time their festivals and ensure the harvests.

But the Greeks who did much to establish the scientific method were philosophers not priests. So religion can't claim it all.
Ha ha ha!
2009-08-13 17:28:10 UTC
It does. People were unsatisfied with explanations like "God did it" for the natural world.
?
2009-08-13 17:27:58 UTC
is that like America having its roots and beginnings in slavery?
James
2009-08-13 17:33:39 UTC
Religion and spirituality has been around for over 3000 years.

Science has been around how long...?
anonymous
2009-08-13 17:40:01 UTC
no that is true, but where it ends is more important then where it begins
Averell A
2009-08-13 17:28:14 UTC
Without God's creation, there can be no science.
Stainless Steel Rat
2009-08-13 17:33:00 UTC
Historically science began with the ancient Greeks. Here is a complete list of ancient Greek scientists. If anything religion and spirituality have gotten in the way. http://www.ics.forth.gr/~vsiris/ancient_greeks/index.html





Agatharchos. Greek mathematician. Discovered the laws of perspectives.

Anaxagoras of Clazomenae (480-430 B.C.). Greek philosopher. Believed that a large number of seeds make up the properties of materials, that heavenly bodies are made up of the same materials as Earth and that the sun is a large, hot, glowing rock. Discovered that the moon reflected light and formulated the correct theory for the eclipses. Erroneously believed that the Earth was flat.

Links: Anaxagoras of Clazomenae, MIT

Anaximander (610-545 B.C.).Greek astronomer and philosopher, pupil of Thales. Introduced the apeiron(infinity). Formulated a theory of origin and evolution of life, according to which life originated in the sea from the moist element which evaporated from the sun (On Nature). Was the first to model the Earth according to scientific principles. According to him, the Earth was a cylinder with a north-south curvature, suspended freely in space, and the stars where attached to a sphere that rotated around Earth.

Links: Anaximander, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anaximander, Encyclopedia Britannica, Anaximander of Miletus, MIT

Anaximenes (570-500 B.C.). Pupil of Anaximander. According to him, the rainbow is a natural phenomenon, rather than the work of a god. Basic principle of the universe is air.

Links: Anaximenes, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anaximenes of Miletus, Encyclopedia Britannica

Andronikos of Kyrrhestes (50 B.C.). Built, in Athens, the Tower of Winds, a water clock combined with solar clocks, the most famous time-keeping device of the Greeks.

Antiphontas. Greek mathematician. Used polygon approximations for the circle to find and approximate vale for pi.

Apollonius of Perga (262-190 B.C.). Mathematician that did a significant amount of work on the conics (circle, ellipse, parabola, and hyperbola). His work was summerized in his book Conics. Considered the last great synthetic geometer until the end of the eighteenth century.

Aristarchus of Samos (310-230 B.C.). Proposed that the sun is at the center of the universe with Earth along with the other planets circulating around it. He estimated the distance of the sun from the Earth by observing the angle between the sun and the moon when it is exactly half full.

Aristotle (Stagira, 390-330 B.C.). Considered the father of life sciences. He was the tutor of Alexander the Great. Undertook the classification of animals and plants at a large scale. His main discovery in embryology was that the mother's contribution is as important as the father's. Believed that the Earth was static and at the center of the universe. He also believed, erroneously, that motion was due to the tendency of all objects to reach there natural state. He discovered that free fall is an accelerated form of motion, but also believed that heavier objects fall faster than lighter ones. He considered chemical elements, which cannot be decomposed, to be the constituents of all bodies. He was the founder of the Lyceum in Athens, also called the peripatetic school because the philosophers were thought while walking.

Archimedes (Syracuse, 287-212 B.C.). Greek mathematician and engineer which is included among the top ranking mathematicians in history. Also a natural philosopher. He demonstrated that all numbers can be written down, by writing down the number of grains of sand needed to fill the entire universe. He expertly used the method of exhaustion developed by Eudoxus. He found ratios of the volumes of various figures, such as that of a sphere and a cylinder with a height equal to the diameter of the sphere which is equal to two thirds. He was the first to apply mathematical laws to levers. He is also known for his discovery that a body immersed in fluid displaces an amount of fluid equal to its own mass. Legend has it that he discovered this while in the bath and later ran naked around the streets of Syracuse shouting Eureka (I have found it). He used levers to pull a fully loaded ship on shore, thus supporting his statement: "give me a lever long enough and a place to stand and I can move the Earth". According to legend he was killed by a soldier while contemplating geometric figures drawn in the sand, even though the soldier's commander had ordered Archimedes' life spared.

Links: Chris Rorres' Archimedes Web Page (Drexel University), Archimedes of Syracuse, University of St Andrews, Scotland, Archimedes, Encyclopedia Britannica

Archytas of Tarentum (420-350 B.C.). Greek mathematician. Built a series of toys, among them a mechanical pigeon propelled by a steam jet. Developed the theory for the pulley.

Callippus (Cyzicus, 370-300 B.C.). Greek astronomer, student of Eudoxus. Showed that at least 34 spheres are needed to account for the movement of the moon, planets, and stars.

Conon (Samos, 300-??? B.C.). Greek mathematician.

Democritus (Abdera, Thrace, 470-380 B.C.). Greek philosopher. Expanded the concept of atoms that was introduced by his teacher Leucippus and showed that atoms are the basis of all form of matter. He recognizes that the Milky Way consists of a number of stars and that the moon is similar to Earth.

Links: Democritus, Encyclopedia Britannica, Democritus, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Democritus of Abdera, University of St Andrews, Scotland

Denostratus. Found a way to square the circle (calculated the ratio of it circumference over its diameter.

Diogenes of Apollonia (600 B.C.) Diogenes was a pupil of Anaximenes, whom he followed in making air the primary element of all things but regarded that there was an intelligent principle behind the order of the Universe. He wrote a number of books on Cosmology.

Diocles (180 B.C.). Investigates properties of the curve he names cissiod (meaning ivy).

Empedocles (Akragas, now Cicily, 492-440 B.C.). Natural philosopher. Introduced the idea of elements. Recognized the heart as the center of a system of blood vessels, but erroneously suggested that the heart is the origin of human emotions. Considered that fire, air, earth, and water as the elementary substances. According to legend, he died by falling into a volcano's crater after failing to become a god as he predicted.

Epicurus of Samos (341-270 B.C.). Founder of a philosophical school where atoms are fundamental parts of the philosophy. Believed that fate was governed by laws of nature and not some mysterious gods.

Eratosthenes of Cyrene (276-200 B.C.).. Greek astronomer and mathematician. Calculated the circumference of the Earth and finds a figure of 46,000 km which is close to the present measured value. Also lays down the first lines of longitude on a map of Earth. He also developed a method for calculating all prime numbers: the sieve of Eratosthenes.

Euclid (300 B.C.). Alexandrian mathematician. Author of Elements, a set of twelve volume that portrayed the geometric thought of the Greeks as it developed in the 6th to 4th century B.C. It includes plane and solid geometry, the theory of incommensurables, and the theory of numbers. Like Plato, he disregarded practicality.

Links: Euclid of Alexandria, University of St Andrews, Scotland, Euclid, Encyclopedia Britannica

Eudemus of Rhodes (340 B.C.). Wrote the History of Mathematics, which is lost however.

Eudoxus of Cnidus (408-360 B.C.). Greek astronomer and mathematician. Belonged to the school of Plato. Developed the theory of proportions and the method of exhaustion.

Gorgias (490-380 B.C.). Greek philosopher. According to his nihilist philosophy, nothing exists. If it did exist we could not know it, and if we new it, we could not tell anyone about it.

Heraklitus (Ephesus, 535-475 B.C.). Considered fire to be the primary form of the real world. According to him, everything is in the process of flux (panta rei).

Heracleides (Heraclea, 390-320 B.C.). Greek astronomer. First to suggest that Venus and Mars may orbit the sun. Also suggested the the Earth rotates around its axis once every 24 hours.

Hipparchus of Nicea (190-120 B.C.) Greek astronomer and mathematician. Developed a system of planetary motion with the Earth at the center. This system was later refined by Ptolemy. Used data from a total eclipse of the sun and parallax to determine correctly the distance and size of the moon. The same data gave values for the distance and size of the sun an order of magnitude smaller than there actual values. Compiled the first tables of cord length, forerunner of trigonometric tables.

Hippasus of Metapontum. Pythagorian philosopher and mathematician. Discovered that some numbers are not commensurable or, in today's terms, not all numbers are rational. Discovered the dodecahedron, a solid whose surface constisted of 12 regular pentagons.

Hippocrates of Cos (460-377 B.C.). Considered as the father of Medicine. He and his followers considered that diseases had a rational explanation and cause, hence could be treated.

Links: Hippocrates, Encyclopedia Britannica

Hippocrates of Chios. Wrote his Elements almost one century before Euclid's.

Hypsicles (180 B.C.). Greek mathematician. It is believed that Hypsicles introduced the 360 degree circle to Greek mathematics.

Inopedes (400 B.C. ?). Greek astronomer. Discovered the obliqueness of the elliptic orbit.

Leucippus of Miletus (490-??? B.C.). Greek philosopher. First to introduce the idea of the atom, an indivisible unit of matter. This idea was later extended by his student, Democretus.

Menaechmus (350 B.C.). Brother of Dinostratus. Wrote about conic sections, showing that they can be used to duplicate the cube.

Meton of Athens (440-??? B.C.). Developed the Meton cycle, a 19-year period in which, as viewed from the Earth, the motions of the Ea


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...