Question:
Do you know why I think God's pre-existence is more logical than the pre-existence of a Big Bang singularity?
2010-10-07 07:46:31 UTC
The Big Bang singularity was supposed to contain a very big, but limited amount of power
The Big Bang is supposed to cause a very huge, but still limited amount of stars.

According to the theory, the Big Bang singularity was finite in its size. It was smaller than a planet.
And the Big Bang singularity existed... where? In empty space? What filled the infinite empty space that was logically needed to be filled outside the singularity?

It is more logical to believe in the existence of a singularity that filled all the infinity of the empty space that existed before our Universe existed.
A singularity that was infinite in all directions. Not a singularity that had a limited size.
That would be God - a energy that always existed, that was infinite in all directions.

What caused God to exist? Let's think... God is supposed to have an infinite amount of power and an infinite size (He is Omnipresent). What caused Him to have an infinite power and presence?

The set of the laws of logic that existed before the Universe needed 'something' to feel the infinite emptiness.

Why does God have a will and a way of communicating with the Creation? Because His self-awareness created that powers.

God EVOLVED from a pre-existing energy into a sentient and complex God because of the laws of logic that existed before the Universe caused Him to. Simply! Because IT WAS NEEDED
Seventeen answers:
Mom
2010-10-07 07:49:54 UTC
If God EVOLVED, as you so put it, does that mean eventually we will all be Gods too?



Scary.
?
2010-10-07 07:49:28 UTC
According to the theory, the Big Bang singularity was finite in its size. It was smaller than a planet.

EFFING GOOGLE WHAT A SINGULARITY IS

0 volume.

>0 mass

= infinite density. these are very special and unique qualities.





"God EVOLVED from a pre-existing energy into a sentient and complex God because of the laws of logic that existed before the Universe caused Him to. Simply! Because IT WAS NEEDED"

leave logic alone, please stop molesting it. logic didnt do you any wrong.
2010-10-07 08:05:33 UTC
really, i believe both happened. and your missing a bit about the physics of the big bang.



the big bang is most likely an infinite system. small dense bit explodes. goes out, forms planets and what not, slows down, stops and reverses. all matter comes back again (gravity causes this), gets all dense and hot. explodes again. and it can be proved very easily with a spectrometer.



but the question you should be asking is, how did life form on a lump of rock at a bazillion to one chance? even an amoeba (the tiniest, weeniest form of single celled life forms) just happen to form? and what started the big bang in the first place?



oh, and btw, the universe is finite in size...
sparky_dy
2010-10-07 08:01:07 UTC
Yes: you think that because your brain does not work properly.



Your laughable attempt to describe the Big Bang shows that you don't understand cosmology. Your preference for the sudden emergence of a complex entity over the gradual accretion of simple entities into more complex entities shows that you don't understand basic principles of logic, either.
Esoteric Order of Dagon
2010-10-07 07:53:58 UTC
No.



What created God? Everything has to have an origin. It doesn't just go poof and then exist. You talk about laws of logic which is ironic since you say something can come from nothing.
2010-10-09 13:40:28 UTC
your argument is invalid...



you suppose that something that encompasses all of everything in existence is less likely to exist than something that isn't seen anywhere in all of existence (infinity)



the singularity existed outside of space-time... it's dimension cannot be measured in 3D

infinitely small = infinitely large if there are no dimensions...
2010-10-07 09:05:48 UTC
Prove logic in any form existed before space and time.
Corey
2010-10-07 07:49:40 UTC
Yes I do know why you think that. Because you don't understand the Big Bang theory, scientific naturalism, or basic critical thinking.



You've done some begging the question, some argument from ignorance, and strawmanning.
2010-10-07 07:49:54 UTC
Your argument is illogical, but then if you are a theist that is nothing new.



Simply put, where did the power of God or origin of God come from then? If your argument is that God is more powerful than the universe... prove it ?



IDIOT!
2010-10-07 07:49:42 UTC
But the existence of "God" is not logical because there is no evidence of it.



We can replace "God" with "Pink elephants" and it would be just as logical by your standards.
?
2010-10-07 07:51:03 UTC
A very small incredibly dense structure can create a larger less dense structure.
2010-10-07 07:50:40 UTC
Our knowledge is still in its infancy. Religion has no new knowledge or updates on the old stuff. And besides, with so many different religions, there would be disagreements
?
2010-10-07 07:51:39 UTC
Stars are still forming and will always be forming. I don't see that being limited
?
2010-10-07 07:48:22 UTC
The main argument against your logic is that you assume God exists in the first place in order to prove his/her/its existence.
Jennifer C
2010-10-07 07:49:05 UTC
I believe in Big Bang!! God spoke and BANG it happened. Hahaha!! Sorry couldn't help myself.
secretsauce
2010-10-07 08:32:25 UTC
Three words: Ev ... id ... ence?
?
2010-10-07 07:49:03 UTC
Yes, it's more logical that an all powerful, thinking being existed (that we've never seen), instead of the things that are obviously there.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...