Question:
Why do Muslims blame the actions of their fellow extremists on 'culture'?
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Why do Muslims blame the actions of their fellow extremists on 'culture'?
Fifteen answers:
Annsan_In_Him
2010-02-08 07:50:08 UTC
This could be because the traditional view of war and violence in the Qur'an is somewhat different to modern Islamic views of those who claim that jihad allows them to practice violence as the extremists do.



The traditional view is that to be actively engaged in holy war, inwardly and outwardly, against everything that negates Truth or God, is to bring peace and harmony - to establish an equilibrium between the destructive forces unleashed when good clashes with evil. Islam has always advocated aggression as a positive and appropriate means of securing peace. But Qur'anic advocacy of holy warfare is interpreted differently by different Islamic groups.



To the mystics, it is spiritualized as a struggle against evil forces within. It is interpreted literally by militants, however, as a struggle to bring unsubdued geographic regions of the world under the dominion of the Islamic faith, politically, legally, and spiritually. So all Muslims who want to be aggressive in spreading the Islamic faith will take that latter view, whilst all Muslims who want Islam to spread peaceably, by others seeing how superior it is to other systems (as they think it is), will be revolted by the jihadists of today. In fairness, the majority of Muslims abhor the extremists in their midst
Devilishly Sexy MasterMinD
2010-02-08 01:01:37 UTC
Intentionally or not, Islam gives many of these extremists the tools and justifications they seek from it.



This is because Islam is ambiguous on many issues and subjects that the extremists manipulate to justify their heinous crimes.



What Muslims need to do is collectively protest against such happenings, so that the whole world gets a clear picture that ''NO, Islam does not condone the actions of the extremists.''
jo n jo
2010-02-08 01:18:24 UTC
No I don't agree with you ,, I advise you to check this website ,

http://www.wakeupproject.com/VList.asp?Series=1
2010-02-08 01:09:35 UTC
If Muslims were terrorists then the entire world would be destroyed



2 billion Muslims living on Earth



less than 1000 are terrorists



Just because the terrorists claim to be Muslim doesn't mean they are Muslim
Bess
2016-04-09 07:45:23 UTC
It's an aspect of the 'right wing authoritarianism' personality disorder: 1. Authoritarian submission — a high degree of submissiveness to the authorities who are perceived to be established and legitimate in the society in which one lives. 2. Authoritarian aggression — a general aggressiveness directed against deviants, outgroups, and other people that are perceived to be targets according to established authorities. 3. Conventionalism — a high degree of adherence to the traditions and social norms that are perceived to be endorsed by society and its established authorities, and a belief that others in one's society should also be required to adhere to these norms
Halal Pig Ok in Islam
2010-02-09 09:29:52 UTC
Chris once again that was a brilliant analysis on your part. Your question is based on logic and facts. I agree that Christians and other groups also exercise the same practices but that was at at time when humans were not as civilized as today. Christians are so civilized now that they let every religion live in peace even though they disagree with others. In this century that we are living in now there is no justification for such barbaric practices. Muslim all over the world should get together to amend the Quran and take away from their holy book the verses that seem to be confusing and exciting terrorist to kill. I think they spend most of their time here on answer defending their religion while they could be doing something more productive like teaching abuse women muslim victims how to stand for their rights. Because that is the true evil of Islam the beating of innocent women and children.
bcgirl
2010-02-08 23:28:23 UTC
Well hello there a curious person, greetings and salutations. so.... i dont know what your idea of culture is, but your question and then the way you elaborated seems a tad contradicting or again maybe it is just your view on what culture is to you. now that being said.....



so in my humble opinion, culture is when a group of people from the same background share a common ground as far as upbringing, child rearing, foods, activities, social events and functions. things of this nature. now, for instance, lets take a city block of houses, and lets say there are 50 houses and in each household just to make it simple lets say all of the families are catholic. so, then being catholic lets say some are from europe, some are canadian, some asian and lets say some african or caribbean as well. so, with all these peole who in a general sense have the same faith, are you telling me that all of these people from all of these different places around the world who happened to of moved and now live next door to eachother, they all have the same culture??? i dont think so. in fact even though all of these people share the same faith, their "cultures" i can tell you are most likely so vastly different that the only thing they would have in common would be their respective faith.



ok, that being said, if you havent figured it out by now, i strongly disagree with your comment/statement above. the entire premise of your account is not backed up by anything factual, only heresay, and i will even go as far to say your opinon may or may not stem from watching too much CNN or the 6'oclock news everyday along with whatever trash is in the daily newspaper.



as far as muslims are concerned and i am a convert myself just to be clear who is writing to you here, and i am here to tell you that of the over 2 billion muslims worldwide?? there are just as many "cultures" to go along with that faith. we all have the same belief in one God/Allah which is just the name God in arabic if you didnt know, so in other words, our faith is just one faith. there are articles of faith,(the belief system) prophets, angels, and its really quite simple as we are not bombarded or confused with having so many choices as these so called "denominations" as christianity has. islam doesnt have a denomination so there is no confusion what-so-ever....



btw, why are there soooo many?? like seriously.... what the difference between christian,catholic,baptist, anglican,orthodox,7th day adventist, church of latter day saints, protestestant, and list goes on and on................



yes alot of muslims disagree on what they think a God fearing muslim is in their own eyes, and thats just judgement, heck we can say that about any faith, and the strong believers alot of the times shun the ones who arent and think everyone is going to burn for their sins..... wow, its amazing how ignorant some people can be, so anyhow and to just touch on these so called extremeists you mention, well again just my opinion, alot has to do with what that group of people has learned and what their interpretation is of the teachings and what they read in the Qur'an. the writings were done during Mohammad's pbuh time, and what is sad, is alot of people are twisting the words and meaning and coming up with their own agendas as to how they again interpret what they are reading. myself i go with what is in my heart, i pray, i read the Qur'an and i dont listen to alot of stuff out there because when i do, i always question the credibility of where that individual got his teaching from. like the net is the worst place to learn of islam, most of it is all twisted up and created by a group of people who are giving their spin on it, see its a catch 22, i hate it but it is..... you want to learn but how do you trust what you are reading?? thats why its best just to read the Qur'an.... and very carefully selected books to read with a discerning eye......



so that being said, culture is what i mentioned above, if 4million people live in a metropolitan city together they do not share the same culture by any means, so your opening sentence on it being an insult to non-mulsims who live in the same culture?? why would you be insulted when realistically you do not share the same culture as them, just the air thats about it.
Paul
2010-02-08 02:09:11 UTC
Well christians play the culture card on verses in the bible we don't like, so I guess the common factor in many if not all religions is to blame culture on the bits from our holy texts we don't like.
2010-02-08 01:16:56 UTC
amysue47 deserves a prize for biggest hypocritical rant on yahoo answers of the day. Merciful butterfly is wrong, there are FAR more than 1000 extremist muslims. Mastermind is the closest to being correct.





Although "suicide bombings, honour killings, FGM, abuses of human rights" aren't only done by Muslims. All groups have their crazies.
Ross
2010-02-08 02:49:11 UTC
It is islam that drives them not culture, the terrorists have mostly studied in the most famous madarassas and universities in the islamic world, they use their prophet as a role model, their mentors are some of the most popular islamic preachers. They proudly recite verses from the quran justifying their actions followed by chest thumping "Allah hu Akbar" just before they attack. So please tell me why this has nothing to do with islam ?



To understand islamic terrorists you first have to understand Mohammad, here's some information about him from the book "Understanding Mohammad" by Ali Sina.



Muhammad is one of the world most influential man indeed, historians tell us Muhammad used to withdraw to a cave, spending days wrapped in his thoughts. He heard bells ringing and had ghostly visions. He thought he was demon possessed, until his wife reassured him he had become a prophet. Convinced of his status, he was intolerant of those who rejected him, assassinated those who criticized him, raided, looted, and massacred entire populations. He reduced thousands to slavery, raped, and allowed his men to rape female captives. All of this, he did with a clear conscience and a sense of entitlement. He was magnanimous toward those who admired him, but vengeful toward those who did not. He believed he was the most perfect human creation and the universe's raison d'être. Muhammad was no ordinary man. Islam is Muhammadanism. Muslims worship and emulate Muhammad. Only by understanding him can one know what makes them tick. Muhammad had a loveless childhood. He then passed to the care of relatives who took pity on him and spoiled him. As the result he developed narcissistic personality disorder, a trait that made him a megalomaniac bereft of conscience. Muhammad believed in his own cause. Even when he lied, he felt entitled and justified to do so. Thanks to another mental illness, namely temporal lobe epilepsy, the prophet of Islam had vivid hallucinations he interpreted as mystical and divine intimations. He also suffered from obsessive compulsive disorder, causing his fixations on numbers, rituals and stringent rules. In the addition, he suffered from acromegaly, a disease caused by excessive production of a growth hormone resulting in large bones and odd facial features. The combination of his psychological disorders and his unusual physiognomy made him a phenomenon that set him apart from ordinary people. His uneducated followers interpreted his differences as signs of his prophethood. Like devotees of all cults, they rose to champion his cause with dedication. By defying death and butchering others they made Islam the world's second largest religion, now the biggest threat to world peace.
Skookum
2010-02-08 01:11:30 UTC
Belief that Allah forgives is enough to cause these actions.

But not to be prejudiced, it's true that any religion's radical fundamentalist faction is destructive and dangerous.
2010-02-08 04:32:11 UTC
Muslims Lie if a Christ ten was to kill a Muslim they blame all Christians!



All Muslims are The Same !
alan h
2010-02-08 01:15:52 UTC
You have a point; but, more often, it is blamed on misunderstanding of the Koran
?
2010-02-08 03:14:59 UTC
how about you answer my question ok.



when christians actually used to follow christianity (i know i did not believe it when i heard it too) that period of time is known as the dark ages, it would seem that christianity brought down the roman empire.



with the muslims the same rule applies (that is that when any faith first begins, its new followers are strict and obedient to the laws of the faith) so why is it that when islam started that instead of the muslims also falling into a similar dark age, they actually fell into a golden age of science and technology.



in case you dont know about the islamic golden age your welcome to look it up, its not just something i am making up.



muslims during the 8th and 12th (some say 16th century) centuries were way more advanced then the christians, only the Chinese could match the islamic world.



now lets look at today, Christians dont follow their religion very well and look how advanced they have got and on the same hand muslims dont follow their religion very well anymore and look how backwards they have become.



and just to give you a small teaser into how life was like in a muslim state back in its golden age.

well they invented street lighting, rubbish collection, universities, public hospitals, restaurants, set meal courses (starter, main and dessert) coffee and coffee houses etc etc



those are just some of the many inventions, what about human rights. well non muslims were not only allowed to practise their own religion but were allowed to be judged in their own courts of law.



for example i am a muslim who lives in the uk, and if i commit a crime i will be sentenced by their courts of law. if you compare you will see that the muslims were even more secular then the west is today. they never banned another peoples beliefs or told them what to wear.



p.s. at around the same time go and check out what Charlemagne was doing to convert europeans to christianity.



"Arab science and philosophy helped rescue the Christian world from ignorance and made possible the very idea of the West" Jonathan Lyons



i am sorry that you think the islam that is practised today is what islam really is because if that is true then i have to tell you that ignorance is holding you back my friend.



after reading this if you feel like you want to know the true answer to your question my advise would be to read or listen on youtube about the life of prophet muhammad and his 4 companions (rashidun) they were the perfect example of what islam is.



i will give you one story from the time of the rashidun, in particular umar ibn al khattab.



ok umar was one of the four companions and become the ruler/caliph after the death of prophet muhammad (pbuh) and abu bakr (another companion).

anyway he lived in medina and it just so happened one day that he was told that he had to travel to jerusalam, so he took his slave and the one camel that he owned. umar decided that he would sit on the camel one day and the next day the slave could sit on it (tell me what ruler did that) anyway so they eventually reach Jerusalem and it is just happened that on the day when he would be entering the city was the same day the slave would be sitting on the camel and umar the ruler of all the muslims and the whole of the middle east would walk in pulling the camel. the slave offered to give his place but umar said it would not be fair.



when he entered all the other muslims said to him, what are you doing, why are you dressed so bad and why are you not sitting on your camel, we have to make a good impression to everybody, your the leader after all. he said “The honour of Islam (i.e., being Muslim) is enough for all of us.” He entered Jerusalem holding the rope of the camel on which was riding his slave. His clothes were dirty and there were several patches on them."





"Yet the abstinence and humility of Umar were not inferior to the virtues of Abu Bakr: his food consisted of barley bread or dates; his drink was water; he preached in a gown that was torn or tattered in twelve places; and a Persian satrap, who paid his homage as to the conqueror, found him asleep among the beggars on the steps of the mosque of Muslims." Gibbon



this is just umar, there is also the prophet muhammad (pbuh), abu bakr (ra), more stories about umar (ra), ali (ra) and all the other companions of the prophet (pbuh).



now ask yourself would the kings of soudi arabia today do the same as what umar did, if the answer is no (which it has to be) then they are not practising islam are you and everybody else seems to think.



EDIT: i think my answer was very relavent to your question. maybe you just did not interpret it right.



what i was trying to get you to see was that, when muslims actually practiced islam they lived in a golden age, now they dont practise islam they are how you see them today.



then i used the example of umar (ra) to show you how muslims should act and i asked you if any muslim king would act the same way today.



i am sorry if this seemed like a history lesson but when you said "Islam which is the inspiration" i had to harken you back to the days when islam was actually practiced to show you that the so called muslims of today dont follow islam, and that if you really want to see islam then you really do have to go and read about those days.



growing up as a muslim i had my doubts about faith, not because i had read the quran, not because i had read about my prophet (pbuh) or his companions but rather because like you and everyone else i thought that the islam practiced by those silly madrasa teachers and tyrants throughout the middle east was really islam.



i actually fell completely away from my faith at one point, only to start reading about the history of islam and what islam really taught did i then come back to islam.



that is why i am telling you the history of islam because it shows the truth of islam.



"I become more than ever convinced that it was not the sword that won a place for Islam in those days. It was the rigid simplicity, the utter self-effacement of the Prophet, the scrupulous regard for pledges, his intense devotion to his friends and followers and his intrepidity, his fearlessness, his absolute trust in God and in his own mission. These and not the sword carried everything before them and surmounted every obstacle”. Ghandi



"I believe that if a man like him were to assume the dictatorship of the modern world, he would succeed in solving the problems in a way that would bring the much needed peace and happiness. Europe is beginning to be enamored of the creed of Muhammad. In the next century it may go further in recognizing the utility of that creed in solving its problems." George Bernard Shaw
Corey
2010-02-08 01:01:46 UTC
So all of Christendom is responsible for the Rwandan genocide, the LRA, and the troubles in the North of Ireland, and church shootings?



No, I don't agree. I think you're a bigot.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...