Question:
Are symbols meaningful or meaningless?
arukas
2010-01-27 05:16:46 UTC
God is not a "rock" and symbols are a useless way of describing God or any religion

Is this true? What's your opinion about this?

My opinion is that its not true since symbols can help you imagine things that are not of our world therefore, can help us imagine and know what God is like by comparing him to worldly things.

I just need to gather opinions and views of different people for my essay
Fourteen answers:
nunya
2010-01-27 05:53:35 UTC
I think that some people are failing to realize the meaning of a symbol. A symbol is more than just a visual sign, like a poster or card, but something that represents or stands for another object, idea, person or concept. It is 100% correct to say that a rock is a symbol for God, for in a figurative sense “rock” describes the qualities of God as the Father of Israel (De 32:18), as a stronghold (2Sa 22:32, 33; Isa 17:10), as the secure height and refuge of his people (Ps 62:7; 94:22), and as their salvation (De 32:15; Ps 95:1). Some have looked to false gods as their “rock.” (De 32:37) There are other examples in which “rock” symbolizes in a general way a place of safety, protection, security, and refuge. (Isa 2:10, 19, 21) In Isaiah 8:14 Christ Jesus is alluded to as “a rock” over which “both the houses of Israel” stumbled.--Mt 21:42-44.



In Bible symbology the sea is used to picture “peoples and crowds and nations and tongues,” the vast body of mankind that cover the habitable earth as the waters cover the sea basins. They are all the people alienated from God by sin and by the “ruler of the authority of the air,” Satan the Devil. (Rev. 17:15; Isa. 57:20, 21; Eph. 2:2)



Certain major world powers of history appear directly in the Biblical record, and all of these, as well as other nations, have used animals as symbols of their governments. . In Egypt, the serpent figured prominently, the uraeus, the sacred asp, appearing on the headdress of the Pharaohs. However, Egypt was also represented by the bull, as was Assyria. Medo-Persia used the eagle (the shields of the Medes bore the golden eagle; the Persians bore an eagle fixed to the end of a lance). Athens was designated by the owl; Rome, the eagle; Great Britain is designated by the lion; the United States, the eagle. From the most remote times China has been symbolized by the dragon. Well known are the Russian “bear” and the German “two-headed eagle.”



Symbols and analogies aren't useless to describe God because it helps our minds wrap around a concept that is bigger than any of us can ever know. Tools like personification give scope to things we normally wouldn't understand, or even dare to try to understand due to its complexity. Representations, signs or symbols bring things down to our level. Even though these representations seldom live up to fully describing all aspects of what they are representing, they still give us a little insight on the matter. Symbols are all around us everyday. It's become a central part of our normal lives to the extent that we sometimes use them without even realizing it. Since they are so common, why shouldn't we use them to better understand the ways of God? Even if they fall short of defining God in His entirety (after all, who can truly describe every facet of the Almighty?) it can still draw us one step closer to His being, and it is probably one step that we could never have fully appreciated without the use of symbols.
smartypatootie
2010-01-27 23:55:21 UTC
what a coincidence! I am writing about this exact same topic [word for word] as an re essay..



some views:



.paul tillich believes that symbols are meaningful as they evoke feelings from inside of us that help us understand religious language more clearly. He also believes that symbols reveal emotions from inside us.

.logical positivists would believe that symbols are meaningless, as you cannot prove whether they are true or false, as no one has ever seen god. Similarly, symbols can be meaningless as they compare God, a spiritual being in a bigger world, to our physical, HUMAN, world.

.God is beyond human experience, therefore we must use symbols to help relate him to us. Also, the believer does not have to take symbols like "rock" or "lamb" literally.



i hope those are enough! you can derive some more views from them :)
Dust
2010-01-27 05:21:30 UTC
Symbols are a way to express ideas without words, which makes them meaningful. However, the meaning of a symbol will often be interpreted differently by people who agree with or oppose the values that so-and-so wants the symbol to express.
2016-04-06 05:37:45 UTC
I think it has to do with exposure and tolerance. if you are exposed to certain things you see what that they should be socially accepted. I think education can really enlighten a person in a ton of ways, and no always changing the attitude of thinking homosexuality is bad or wrong. As far as social status, thats a really interesting question. I would think that if you are part of a lower social status and gay it would be harder to come out and such because its much more of a risk. When getting married is a way of moving up in social status, and i'm not saying thats the only reason but i would also think it has something to do with lack of exposure and overall education. If you dont go to school you are most likely around the same people attaining the same beliefs. Just a thought..
Secret Agent of God (BWR)
2010-01-27 05:22:47 UTC
Saying God is like a rock isn't a symbol, it's an analogy.



That's why it's so difficult to share my relationship with God with others. I cannot describe it with our limited vocabulary. I can only tell people about the joy I feel in my heart. That's difficult, too, though, because not everyone knows what joy feels like until they HAVE found God.



And that's why we so often need desperation to be the pathway to God.
2010-01-27 05:27:11 UTC
Yes, God is not a rock. A rock is just one of His creations.

Nothing in this world can be used as a comparison to His Most Beautiful Self.

He is not to be imagined.
imrod
2010-01-27 05:19:43 UTC
If symbols did not convey meaning you would not have been able to express this question here in this format and I would not have been able to answer. You cannot write your essay if symbols aren't meaningful. Letters and words are symbols.
2010-01-27 05:19:25 UTC
A symbols meaning is given by the person that sees it.



All symbols have an inherent value of zero, until humans decide to inflate its value.
Mitchincredible
2010-01-27 05:19:43 UTC
Symbols are important for representing vast psychological concepts in simple to understand ways, they're like a .rar for concepts. The same can also be said for archetypical figures.
Rocky Squirrel
2010-01-27 05:25:16 UTC
A picture is worth a 1000 words.
jaicee
2010-01-27 05:29:34 UTC
It is impossible to express subtle ideas concretely, and spiritual concepts and truths are abstruse and subtle. Symbols, allegories, and metaphors are essential to communicate them.
2010-01-27 05:24:16 UTC
You can never compare God to any symbol or image.He is God.symbols are just images.Only your faith can help you to know God.
Freedom
2010-01-27 05:27:28 UTC
symbols are a representation of relationships.if not used properly they are meaningless or misleading.
Mary
2010-01-27 05:22:29 UTC
be a symbol if you want



i'm not going to necessarily believe you exist though.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...