Atheists or Agnostics, who created Qu'ran in your opinion?

Question

I believe Allah (SWT) created the Qu'ran.

DO NOT include "oh the man created it." I don't want to hear "the man" answer because that does not answer the question. If it is your answer, then how????????

Plus, if you had a chance to go to Mecca and found the tomb of Prophet Muhammed (peace be upon him), what would you do?

That it is real?

Answer 1

You ask how then? Same way the Bible was "created". Some MEN took some pieces of paper (parchment), quills, & some ink and started writing. Then some other MEN bound all those pieces of written on parchment together and passed them out.

Answer 2

Kid; this is NOT how Y!A works.

It's a Q&A site.

That means you ASK a question and we ANSWER the question.



You are either a CHEAT or you aren't bright enough to understand that this is NOT a site for proselytizing.

Proselytizing is AGAINST community guidelines.



As for who 'created' Qur'an ?

Mo' had it 'created' after he told his boys what to write.



Neither Allah nor any other brand of invisible sky critter exists.

I don't have to think too deeply to realise that invisible space wizards were made up by crafty little old men to scare and or scam peasants and small children.



If I look at the available evidence I see that haphazard mayhem happens to everyone regardless of thought or deed EXACTLY as if there was NO invisible magician up in the sky pulling the strings.



There are NO invisible monsters under the bed, in the closet, up in the sky or any other place godsters like to hide them; they are nothing more than evidence of a fertile imagination.



"Plus, if you had a chance to go to Mecca and found the tomb of Prophet Muhammed[sic – please have respect; learn to spell it correctly] (peace be upon him), what would you do?"

I could afford to go tomorrow but why would I?

I have NO interest in looking at cemeteries or finding tombs.



"HOW in the world can a man create Qu'ran[sic – * it is spelled Qur’an]?!"

Books are written every day; some of them are even interesting and well written.

Please stop thinking invisible space thingies came down here and wrote your book - that would have to mean that every other 'god' ever invented wrote their own book too.



Have you any idea how many 'gods' have been invented by crafty little old men down through the ages?

THOUSANDS.



Grow up.

~

Answer 3

I am neither an atheist nor an agnostic, but this is a pretty easy question. Mohammed invented the Koran and his followers wrote it down. Simple, see?



EDIT:



Nobody is denying the existence of Muhammed, we (non-Muslims) just do not agree that he was a prophet and that he got the Koran from an angel.



EDIT:



How in the world would a man create the Koran? The same way that man could create the Arabian Nights or Lord of the Rings: An active imagination.

Answer 4

Don't ask the question, if you don't want to hear the answer.



P.S.: How come in heaven, Allah will feed you honeyed figs? Is this because that was the best treat the man who wrote the Koran could think of? Why not ice cream, or something more delicious. Obviously, Allah would know about chocolate bars, being omnipotent and all. So why (yeck) honeyed figs.



If a scripture is anacronistic, then it is rooted in a certain time, hence not universal, hence not divine.

Answer 5

Okay, I think I get what you're saying. But there is nothing in the Qu'ran that couldn't have been dictated by an intelligent man with a good knowledge of science and religion as it stood in his day, and excellent poetry skills. Look at the Iliad; it was oral poetry dictated by an illiterate and no one argues that its supernatural.

Answer 6

Man wrote the Koran along with every other book and religion on earth.



Every religion is a derivative of the universal truths that mankind has discovered. Islam can be traced back to Christianity, and Christianity can be traced back to Greek philosophy and Eastern thought. This knowledge was the very basis of oral traditions in the form of the Vedas. Every religion is derived from this. How did they discover this? Time and suffering led them to inquire the nature of mankind. It was their own inquiry that lead to the realization, and that inquiry can be done right here and now by your own mind.

Answer 7

Men wrote all the religious texts found in this world.



God is not a bigot.





Any religion that claims to be the only way to God is based on deceit and lies.





Religions are invented by people with an agenda. The words are from the imigination of men and then more men alter those words according to their agenda.





Muhammed AND Paul both had an agenda that was to further their position and fill up their purses.



Add the leaders of the early churches/mosques, who learned early just how to control the masses to further their own greedy purposes.

Answer 8

Muhammed Ali

Answer 9

Just take a pen and a stack of paper. Easy does it. I really don't see the problem. Maybe you could say which parts could not possibly be created by humans?



No idea what the fact that Mohammed existed has to do with anything.

Answer 10

i'm getting the psychology of why they suspect yet no longer the rational so no. i do no longer seem around and see the writer. I see nature merely. they might cite the butterfly, kittens, new child toddlers, sunsets, and rainbows yet they seem to forget the butterfly demise in the spider information superhighway, toddlers who're born with terrible delivery defects or illnesses, the thoroughly organic motives we've for a manner those issues artwork. they ought to motel to introducing a clean fictional character without info for issues like delivery defects, ailment, "evil" mutually as technological information delivers logical motives supported by capacity of info. they only argument they have in any respect that i ought to at one time kind of see is the beginning of the universe. the actual answer although is merely we don't understand. A naturalistic rationalization is extra possibly to me merely as a naturalistic rationalization replaced our perception demons brought about epilepsy, Zeus threw lightening, sin brought about ailment, and so on.... i seem on the very foundation of the predator/prey device the international is predicated upon and good judgment precludes the form of god maximum everybody is peddling at any fee.

Answer 11

What you should do is read anything by Zecharia Sitchin and you will discover that the Qu'ran as well as the bible were plagarized from the Sumerian tablets from 6000 years ago.

Answer 12

You don't want to hear the answer "man did it" without explanation?



Hmmm. Let's see. How could a man write a book? How is this possible that man could sit down and write a book?



Your right, it's impossible. It had to be God.

Answer 13

Muhammad was no Prophet because there is no God. A MAN wrote the Qur'an. NO divine intervention occured.

Answer 14

The koran was written by men (just like the torah and the bible) , and propagated by men through fear and ignorance (just like the torah and the bible).



All religious writings are superstitious nonsense based on ancient myths.

Answer 15

Muslim, who created The Lord of the Rings in your opinion?



DO NOT include "oh the man created it." I don't want to hear "the man" answer because that does not answer the question. If it is your answer, then how????????

Answer 16

sorry that you don't like my answer, but I stand by it. A man wrote it.



I'm not sure I would want to visit Mecca. Or anyone's tomb.



Edit: There are these people. They're called writers. They write stuff. Sometimes it's successful, sometimes it's not. Sometimes entire religions are based on what they write.

Answer 17

Didn't Muhammed write it or at least most of it? I would behave the same way as if I were at the wailing wall or the vatican, or the veitnam memorial, with a strong respect for those who revere it.

Answer 18

after mohammed died his followers wrote it down





and what do you mean if i find his tomb?



people know where his tomb is



and you ask a question then tell people not to answer it a certain way



thats odd

Answer 19

Why isn't man an answer? That's the only way I can figure out all these religious books were written.

Answer 20

Mohamed did. And in Arabic, it's a quite beautiful hymn to God. But like every other holy book, it's not God's hymn to man.

Answer 21

It was written by Muhammed

Answer 22

Okay, I will not give the simple "man" answer.



The man that lived one sheep herd over from the bible writers wrote it.

Answer 23

Pedophilic con man

Answer 24

You ask a question, but you forbid us to give a certain answer?



Some man or perhaps men wrote it. I don't know who.

Answer 25

A man...with a pen and a lot of time and creativity.

Answer 26

A psychopath.

Answer 27

Man did. He wrote it, using a pencil.



Muhammed, poo be upon him, was a real child molester. Nobody denies that. What is disputed is his prophetness.

Answer 28

An illiterate, warmongering pedophile dictated it to his ex-Catholic older wife.



I'd spit on that bastards tomb.

Answer 29

It was written like any other book...

Answer 30

Zeus.

Answer 31

Mohammad with the help of a scribe.

Answer 32

If you don't want an answer, why ask the question.



I think the same type of people that wrote the bible, wrote the qu'ran.



Men wanting dominance.

Answer 33

uhhhh... starts with an m, ends with an n, and in the middle is an e.

Answer 34

Just another male chauvinist.

Answer 35

Ancient humans. (I didn't say man!)

Answer 36

Just like the bible.................man

Answer 37

muslim godgobbers

Answer 38

I am a Christian but I will answer your question. Satan himself created the Qu'ran. Islam is a religion created by Satan to lead man from God and Mohammed is a not a prophet at all but he was a tool of Satan.

Answer 39

thor.

Answer 40

muhammed with the help of the devil..