Question:
Noah's ark, where did all that rain come from?
random mentalist.
2007-09-28 11:02:58 UTC
if there was so much rain that it flooded all the land then where did all that rain come from, i.e, there was not that much sea or water in the first place, how can clouds vaperate more water than what was allready there in the first place.
36 answers:
darkdiva
2007-09-28 11:07:34 UTC
It's my understanding that to form the oceans in the first place, the earth's surface cooled and condensed causing it to rain for, I think the figure quoted, was 2 million years.
kent_shakespear
2007-09-28 11:15:03 UTC
Three possibilities:



1. As a magical event, the rain was magic, or magic transported the rain from (and later, presumably, back to) an extraterrestrial place. Likewise, magic would be needed to house 1.6 billion species on a single vessel, and allow each to repopulate without running into genetic difficulties from lack of diversity (i.e. incest).

2. It did not happen at all. It was either made up or a parable.

3. The story was inspired by a real flood that was not global, but magnified and exaggerated over time.



The problem with (1) is that it takes an awful large amount of extra effort; if a god is responsible for the laws of physics, then they would likely be based upon his own example: the path of least resistance. it would have been just as easy for an omnipotent god to inflict a human-specific disease upon all humans; his 'chosen' could be either immune or sequestered away. This suggests that the story is not literal; interpretations were added.



The problem with (2) is that while a global flood of the sort described is, without magic, clearly impossible based on the evidence, there have been enough localized floods that could have inspired the story (as per #3). The flooding of the Black Sea alone could be a likely inspiration; even My. Ararat is not far away.
quietgrandpaforchating
2007-09-28 11:52:15 UTC
Ok...there are 30 or more answers to your question, containing all manner of proposals intermixed with some science and details.



May I submit another? There is in the internet a site where in a scientist makes another proposal which seems to follow in part some of these other submitions. There are some differences in his attempt to show with some scientific evidence to support his proposal. Go to the site and read it in more complete form then I can repeat here.



the site is Bob Gentry creation halos and the center of the universe www.halos.com that is a Google search



In it and an available film there is considerable animation to also explain where in the water came from. Even an explanation of the forming of the Grand Canyon, ancient coal and oil deposits.



In a quick answer, following the Biblical account of the "fountains of the deep arrupting" there is an expalantion of the earths outer shell being moved about do to the water which came from above in the sky and that which was stored below the earths surface. Bare in mind how we obtain fresh water now, is to a great extent from wells and pumping water from beneath the earths surface.



Of course you can disregard looking the information or discount it, but at least this is a better expalnation then what most people are even considering to any extent. It also has a great Biblical connection for those whom wish to believe.
Sir Network
2007-09-28 21:34:53 UTC
If it was done by God before recorded history began, then don't you think it's a bit hard to speculate on the science?



With that said, here's the verse:

"on the same day all the fountains of the great deep burst open, and the floodgates of the sky were opened"



All underground aquifers could empty onto the surface because of a massive tectonic plate shift. That's happened in recorded history.

Massive purges of relative humidity in the form of rain happen for many reasons. In the central USA, dry lines often form in the eastern Rockies. When they sweep eastward, they cause a massive buildup of moisture over the southern plains, usually resulting in massive downpours and severe thunderstorms.



Hope this helps.
2007-09-29 17:27:47 UTC
The same place that any other rain comes from. Clouds.



OK that was a smart-*** answer.



This is not a politcal question and I hope no one gives you a politcal answer.



You have to understand the dynamics surrounding a storm system and the only way to do that is ask a meteorologist or climatologist, or anyone who studies weather for a living or a hobby.



Your question is a good one though.
Seargent Gork
2007-09-28 11:06:52 UTC
The history channel did a wonderfull show on this, you see to the people in that area at the time, the whole world was a small peice of land, it did rain, the river flooded, and noah on something much less than the ark people think of floated down south and hit greece i think, he had a few farm animals with him at the time. He actually thought the world had flooded, but in reality it did not.
Drop short and duck
2007-09-28 11:12:52 UTC
Massive Climate Change caused by a meteorite hitting the other side of the earth in the Gulf of Mexico and the after effects of too much carbon and ash in the atmosphere which caused all the ice to melt around the globe.



That's when you could walk from Europe to Britain.
washington m
2007-09-28 11:11:09 UTC
well there was no rain.......

no ark no animals.

the real story is, Iberian peninsula .. where Spain and Morocco meets was closed out, earth quake, let the water from the Atlantic flood the land.. making the Mediterranean sea... flooding hundreds of cities.. that's the famous flood..



remember the bible is a religious book, believing in the ark is like believing the earth was created in 7 days
Someone who cares
2007-09-28 11:12:45 UTC
The rain came from the sky. And it is true that clouds cannot evaporate more water then they contain. It is not the only source for the flood waters though....



The water for the flood also came from the "fountains of the great deep".



http://news-info.wustl.edu/news/page/normal/8222.html
grumpyfiend
2007-09-28 11:08:27 UTC
Rain comes from where rain comes from. Every drop of water from the beginning of creation, except what has been brought into space on purpose, has always been either in the oceans, and other bodies of water, or in the clouds.
2007-09-28 11:07:47 UTC
A portion did in fact come from rain, but if you had read the account you would have also have found

"All the springs of the great deep burst forth and the floodgates of the heavens were oppened"
2007-09-28 11:18:30 UTC
Water from Atlantic broke Gibraltar and made mediterranean sea
Connie D
2007-09-28 11:09:14 UTC
The belief is that it was not just rain water but water rising fron within the earth. I think if god is capable of everthing else he created he would be capable of making some extra water.
2007-09-28 11:08:01 UTC
there used to be a water canopy completely covering the earth. It, some theologists say, protected against all the suns rays. It collapsed, and with all the ground water coming up as well, completely flooded the earth.
2007-09-28 11:07:26 UTC
every culture has a flood myth! the story of Noah is actually believed to be the Sumerian story of Noah who's kingdom was wiped out in a river flood. but a lot of scientists will tell you it's very likely that there was something that caused a world wide flood that inspired all these stories.
Tim
2007-09-28 11:07:06 UTC
There was a flood. Floods happen. Was the whole world flooded? Most likely not. Was there a huge flood that covered a large area? Seems probable.
KrzyMom2
2007-09-28 11:05:41 UTC
Read Genesis in the Bible ... There used to be a canopy of water than went above the earth. It broke open and the earth flooded. Also, remember, God can do anything!
larissa
2007-09-28 11:06:49 UTC
Maybe there wasn't a flood all over the earth but just on a part of it. They woud not have known anyway, there were no phones or internet back then...
2007-09-28 11:26:45 UTC
ppl say that god can do everything but that is not true at all. god can not do everything. if god could do everything couldn't he take all the ppl in hell and put them in heaven? he cant do that cause cause he would be a liar and god is not a liar.god could lie but he wont thus he cant do all things. as far as the question goes if god said it happened it did it doesent matter how he did but he did it
Pirate AMâ„¢
2007-09-28 11:10:23 UTC
It's a myth, or to use some Xian terms a metaphor.



And you're right, there is not enough Hydrogen to make that much water.
woojas
2007-09-28 11:05:48 UTC
Heaven
Vacationer
2007-09-28 11:06:38 UTC
I think the theory is that there was more water in the atmosphere then. The seas probably weren't as big. who knows
2007-09-28 11:06:30 UTC
God did it for a purpose. God is all powerful he can do anything. Even make tons of rain.
2007-10-01 03:35:29 UTC
i got a question for you...

where does it rain the most???











you'll never guess!!

























got it yet?



















i'm not tellin!

















ok wait...



















the shower!!! hahaha















was that funny? i found it was

About your question well...

i really dnt know
PandaJ
2007-09-28 11:06:22 UTC
The Canopy Theory has an explanation for that, but it's largely disputed. Check out the link below, you might find it interesting.
2007-09-28 11:06:17 UTC
The rain came from God. There doesn't need to be any scientific explanation. God is above and beyond science.
nocateman
2007-09-28 11:07:24 UTC
It came from the sky man, from God, he can do that you know!
dontmesswithheather
2007-09-28 11:05:38 UTC
GOD! He made it rain and protected Noah's ark





EDIT: GOD makes miracles
Random Nickname
2007-09-28 11:06:22 UTC
it didn't just rain, water gushed up from the earth as well.
Megegie
2007-09-28 11:05:45 UTC
The imaginations of those who wrote the Bible.
Katie
2007-09-28 11:06:47 UTC
it came from the clouds...more water was produced...it is possible because it happend...with god all things are possible...good luck!!!
2007-09-28 11:05:32 UTC
It came from God. Isn't that the whole point?
2007-09-28 11:06:08 UTC
ok honey..just watch the ball and........swiiiiiiiing





answer: God can do anything.
2007-09-28 11:05:07 UTC
god pee'd on the earth
r0bert999yay
2007-09-28 11:06:52 UTC
god
2007-09-28 11:05:04 UTC
god !


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...