Please take a look, a muslim on here said that stoning a woman?

Question

woman to death is RIGHT.
please take a look at what ABIR, THE LAST GUY , responded.
WE NEED TO STOP THIS RELIGION OF VIOLENCE.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070720013424AAtyO7T&r=w#FpIuXGfuAmTp9uuzIFDOskyZz4pDasnxWay0p99U0rXLJHnusNiI

Answer 1

A religion is nothing more than a "rabid, rampaging cult" if it begins thousands of years ago and never ever changes to keep up with the times!



Why would any 21st century contemporary man or woman continue to accept the beliefs of ancient, uneducated, primitive goat herders and sandal-makers? It's absurd! The people who founded religions a thousand years ago were barbarians! Hopefully we evolve as time passes, into more compassionate, less blood-lusting lunatics!



Just because they used to tie a man's hands and feet to four horses and rip his limbs from his torso in a death sentence called "draw and quarter" doesn't mean that this sort of savage, base behaviour still exists today! Hopefully we evolve from hysterical animalism to civilized rationalization!! Have Muslims no free will to change their more brutish, antiquated doctrines???



Islam is and will remain a primitive, violent religion as confirmed by their own people! On that note, it is doomed to never grow out of the stone age. It is dangerous and out of control. It's worse than faiths that allow their believers to watch their babies writhe and scream in agony as they die from lack of medical attention while "God" is relied upon to intervene in the illness.



Just savage.



.

Answer 2

My friend, what do you not understand in all this unless you support adultery?



I have not seen the video but I am assuming that the persons being stoned WERE adulterers. In this case try to understand the following:



Consider a soceity where everyone is free to marry. There are no economic and social restrictions. Norms are such that getting married is encouraged and made easy by the soceity for everyone.



There are no "temptations" in terms of possibilities of seduction by a man of a woman or vice versa due to the social laws and rules in practice.



Men and women interect with each other as individuals, looking beyond their gender differences in every day matters of life. In personal life each man and woman is emotionally and sexually satisfied with their spouse.



Divorce is easy to get. Any man or woman who fears that he or she cannot love the spouse and remain faithful to him or her is free to seek divorce and remarry.



This is a mocel Islamic system. If in such a system, someone (man or woman) commits adultery then it is really serious. It sure shows a certain twist of the mind. When all moral avenues of life are open for enjoying sexual pleasures then what is the justification for resorting to immoral and forbidden activities? Also, for the Islamic punishment to be in place, it means there have been wintnesses and knowing the Islamic emphasis on privacy, it implies that the adulterous act has been probably done publicly. So for such reckless people, what option is left but to carry out the legal punishment.



The demerits of adultery are far reaching than mere "personal matter". It spoils trust, ruins families, endangers new generation and what not.



However, for such strict Islamic punishment to be in place one has to ensure that all avenues of wrong doing are fully addressed and closed. That is why in Islam a rapist's sentence is death, that is why a man who wrongly accuses a woman of adulterous behavior is subjected to strict physical punishment, and that is why adultery is so strictly punishable because ALL avenues of evil are completely blocked in an Islamic soceity.



You are also wrong in making it sound as if it is suppression of women. The punishment is for both man and woman.

Answer 3

Muslim worldwide places like Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and others signify Islam. in the event that they mistreat women human beings then the worldwide will see Islam as an abusive faith. It does not EVER be counted what ANY faith says. the only element that concerns is how the individuals who persist with the religion act and take care of others. The leaders of the Islamic faith ought to take a no longer elementary stand on subjects such an newborn brides, family members violence, rape, honor killings, and different such issues. quite the worldwide gets to take heed to some Saudi choose order a rape sufferer to be crushed and Islamic leaders asserting that if a woman does not disguise up a guy won't be able to administration himself and he or she will have the skill to be raped. I understand that that may no longer your view or your faith. you have a private relationship with God by this faith. yet to an outsider we won't be able to see your coronary heart by all the abuse. EDIT: particular!! Now you're starting to be it. We affiliate different Muslim human beings's incorrect doings with Islam!! ALL Muslim human beings signify Islam, in simple terms like each Christian human beings signify Christianity. If somebody does something poor contained in the call of there faith then it supplies their faith a bad call. it incredibly is all absolutely everyone seems to be asserting. religious leaders have a duty to place a give up to that variety of habit by publicly affirming that undesirable absolutely everyone isn't component of their faith and then actively and aggressively helping people who've been oppressed. regrettably that may no longer the case in Islamic worldwide places. And by the way Christians do no longer worship the Virgin Mary. i do no longer comprehend why you think of we would persist along with her in any way. i assume it incredibly is in simple terms a pretend impression you have approximately Christianity.

Answer 4

BOTH MAN and WOMAN (adulterer and adulteress) should be punished. Get your facts straight.



By the way, Abir is a girl's name.



Edit:



Quote: "Also you need to get your facts straight, the q'ran advocates for stoning of women not men. READ THE Q'RAN MY DEAR."



Can you provide a verse corroborating this...?

Answer 5

What about all the Christians doing the Crusades, the Inquisition, the Holocaust, etc...



What about Israel bombing Pakistan (I'm not choosing sides, I'm just stating the fact) into the stone age?



ALL RELIGIONS ARE VIOLENT.



This is not an Islamic problem. This is a religious problem.

Answer 6

um hang on before you go off all gun ho.....the NEW Testament (Romans) says homosexuals (those "without natural affection") and their supporters (those "that have pleasure in them") are "worthy of death." 1:31-32



So pot calling the kettle black mean anything to Christians?... not that 'peace' has said whether he/she is or isnt

Answer 7

WOW! The answerer clearly said both adulterer and adultress! yet you jump on the women are killed and oppressed in Islam band wagon!



In Islam a woman has a right to divorce, there is no need for adultery!

Answer 8

I think the judgment of an Adulterer should be left to God



The stoning, probaby is metaphoric, made to understand the severity of this sin, does it need to be taken literally?

Answer 9

It is not surprising when you consider the source...

http://www.americanthinker.com/2005/06/muhammad_and_the_jews.html

Answer 10

I've said this all along, only to receive thumbs down galore and called "intolerant". I know exactly what the Qu'ran teaches and it is no friend of a woman. Islam is truly a religion of hate and violence. One only has to read the passages of it's book to see that.

Answer 11

What about burning in hell for eternity? Religion has some nasty punishments.

Answer 12

Not every Muslim is violent... you can't judge a whole religion soley based on one persons stupidity...

Answer 13

The problem is: they're obeying their scripture!! We can't make them believe just the parts we like.



This is the problem with religion.



As long as people believe in absurdities they will continue to commit atrocities. ~Voltaire

Answer 14

When thou comest nigh unto a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace unto it.

And it shall be, if it make thee answer of peace, and open unto thee, then it shall be, [that] all the people [that is] found therein shall be tributaries unto thee, and they shall serve thee.

And if it will make no peace with thee, but will make war against thee, then thou shalt besiege it:

And when the LORD thy God hath delivered it into thine hands, thou shalt smite every male thereof with the edge of the sword: But the women, and the little ones, and the cattle, and all that is in the city, [even] all the spoil thereof, shalt thou take unto thyself; and thou shalt eat the spoil of thine enemies, which the LORD thy God hath given thee. Thus shalt thou do unto all the cities [which are] very far off from thee, which [are] not of the cities of these nations. -- Deu 20:10-15



[64] Chavel 1967, v.I, 200f. The Bible references are Deuteronomy 20.



There are two types of war applicable to the 21st Century believers :



1. milhemet hova (obligatory war)

2. milhemet reshut (optional war)



This obligation is commented by Rabbi Chavel:



"This Commandment ... will be better understood in the light of the following passage from the 'Mishneh Torah': '



We are not to engage in war with anyone whatever unless we [first] proclaim peace to him; [this is applicable to both] an optional and an obligatory war; for it is said, When thou drawest nigh a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace unto it (Deut XX, 10).



If [the inhabitants] accept the offer of peace... we are not to slay a soul among them, and they merely become tributary, for it is said, [All the people ... therein] shall become tributary unto thee, and shall serve thee'." (Ibid.)



****** OT COMMAND BY THE LORD OF ABRAHAM : *****



Step 1 --- Give them the option of peace (to become believers)

Step 2 ---- If they want to keep their religion, they must pay the Tribute (Head Tax)

Step 3 ---- If they deny the above two options then kill them all or enslave them.



In other words, if the city's inhabitants object to being subdued/enslaved, they have to be slain nevertheless. Also sparing their life directly contradicts Negative Commandment 49 (see note [65]).



"We must not make a covenant with idolaters, to agree on keeping peace with them or accept them practising idolatry, because it says (Deut 7:2) Thou shalt not make a covenant with them. Either they give up idolatry or they are killed. And it is forbidden to pity them, since it says (ibid.): Nor shalt thou shew mercy unto them.



http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/guido_deimel/judaism.html#46





The above references the command from the OLD TESTAMENT which according to Judaic law is applicable for all time and for all believers.





If Christians believe Jesus is God then he is the God of the Old Testament and therefore they cannot deny that GOD commanded this for the believers.





///