Question:
Is Hell a spiritual state of mind of being separated from God?
?
2016-01-09 08:40:12 UTC
This would make more sense to me than the literal "fire, brimstone, physical torture" hell that most Christians believe in.

If this is correct then we are already in either Hell or Heaven, it is a state of mind that we immerse ourselves in and grow after death.

Is this accurate or would as a Christian say that I am "heretical"? All I want is to not believe here is a place after death called "Hell" where God literally throws people into for eternal torture.
Eighteen answers:
anonymous
2016-01-09 08:51:03 UTC
You are right, a state of mind is real, so hell and heaven are real also. And it is a place of suffering because of a person being separated from God. Otherwise if one is connected with God, even while living in hell, it becomes like heaven, and heaven would be hell if one could not experience the presence of God. God is above heaven and hell, or good and bad.
anonymous
2016-01-09 08:44:07 UTC
If the universe collapses through gravity, once all the propulsion runs out, which it must due to the first law of thermodynamics, then it will cause another big bang, like always. Everything that can possibly happen will happen an infinite amount of times. It just depends on what you make possible, as every time you are reincarnated, you decide on your own actions, which plays a big part in what happens to you, and how you feel about it. Oh, and the valley of Gehenna was a real place as well, with real sulfur and brimstone, that really burned people alive for sins.
?
2016-01-09 08:44:12 UTC
nope.. you're not "heretical"... there are multiple interpretations of "hell" and yours is called "eternal separation"... more and more catholics are leaning toward this interpretation, instead of eternal torment (ironically, another Western/Latin Christianity [modern day Roman Catholic] concoction).



The only way that you are "heretical" is if a council of bishops from all walks of the faith, deem your view as such... and not from a bigot arbitrarily calling it such.

----------------

If you're wondering here are the major views of hell or the most common views:



1. Pop Infernalism: Infernalism refers to the belief that those who do not receive Jesus as Lord and Saviour in this lifetime enter hell, defined as eternal conscious torment in the lake of fire, immediately upon death.



2. Final Judgment Infernalism: (Same as the first but only during the final judgement)



3. Annihilationism: Relative to Final Judgement Infernalism, however, rather than experiencing eternal conscious torment, the damned will be completely consumed by the fire and they will be destroyed or annihilated.



4. Conditional Immortality: unbelievers have no further opportunity to enter eternal life once they die. Thus, death itself will be the final judgment and the whole person will simply ‘perish.’



5. Ultimate Redemption: unbelievers will experience divine judgement consistent with their rejection of Christ in this life. The hell in this judgment is pictured as exclusion from the City of God, But there is always an ongoing invitation and opportunity to respond to Christ and to enter the gates of the New Jerusalem



6. Evangelical Universalism: Others profess that Christian faith includes confidence (not just hope) in the ultimate, universal salvation of all humankind through the work of Christ. This may involve either an extended process or a moment whereby everyone passes through the refining, purifying fire of God’s love that ultimately cleanses and restores everyone to fellowship with God.



7. Pop Universalism: Pop Universalism says that all will be welcomed into eternal life at some point, because on the Cross, Christ has already met every condition for our salvation.



As you can see, a great range of interpretations exists on this continuum. For each view, more Scriptures could be added and many other Scriptures can be employed in rebuttal.

----------------

If you're wondering the view of the church fathers or which view is in-line with biblical orthodoxy and church history...



It's:

Universalism/Inclusionism - 4/6

Annihilationism - 1/6

Eternal Torment - 1/6
anonymous
2016-01-09 08:48:25 UTC
Yeah, I would say so:



The Kingdom of the Devil -

Some say a continuum of untold suffering. "In the world"

A much less spiritual realm – Ego/Eros, in spiritual darkness "I, Me and My" - The Bully is lost and blames the victim - Unconscious lies - To be in the world and of the world - Strange eyes, Darkling thoughts, Machination, Avarice, Cupidity ~ Hypocrisy, (Monogamy ~ The ego seeks a nest), Promiscuity, Adultery, Polygamy (Idolatry ~ To attentively Bewilder and Beguile with Pernicious Lies, and advocate flesh/Lasciviousness/wanton lewd)

To be Shallow and Judgemental, Insecure, to Scoff, to be Sardonic, to Rejoice as in a day of slaughter nourishing hearts in Zion.

Mentality and spirituality being fused:- Narcissism, Munchausen's. Subjudacy, Subversion, Subterfuge and Black-male etc. (Individually and collectively)

To be UN-empathetical to the truth (Lies need a stage, the truth does not) - Hence the stage:



REGARDING "HELL AS A LITERAL PLACE" What do we think Hell really is? Old Testament (Hebrew) - Sheol is just the grave. New Testament (Greek) - Hades is just the grave. If you were taught that it is an eternal burning fire, stoked by Satan, please realize that the Bible says at Revelation 20:10, Revelation 20:13, 14, and Revelation 21:8 that Hades and Satan are both destroyed. No Satan+No Hades, means there is no eternal burning hellfire

***************************************
yesmar
2016-01-09 08:41:36 UTC
It's a state of being in the technical sense of the word, yes, because it is death, oblivion, ceasing to exist for eternity. The only way to be "separated" from a God who is aware of everything, is to not exist.



Going down the road to get there can certainly be a state of mind.
Trilobiteme
2016-01-09 08:53:20 UTC
Fool on the Hill God created the Universe If you look at the universe there are many things that are extremely hot.

Only a fool would think God does not have the power to create hell. The Bible says that the Lake of fire exists for enemies of God
capitalgentleman
2016-01-09 08:59:48 UTC
If you actually read, and study the Bible, you will see that Hell is death. Once there, you are nothing - literally. There is no "life" in Hell - no eternal torture. A real separation from God, and everything else too.
?
2016-01-09 10:07:27 UTC
To start REAL Defined as EXISTING AS a THING Occurring in FACT ( verified ) NOT Imagined ( thought ) Or Supposed



. See Psychology Today Thoughts are not "REAL" they do not exist out side your mind No other human being can Know your thoughts or experience them . so they are not a thing they are Imagined a product of the brain awareness of self there is no Spirit in your mind its chemicals and electrical firing of synapses impulses



a product of human senses Your ear drum vibrates you hear the vibration sends a perception to your brain same as vision touch speech is vibration of the vocal cords we do pattern recognition of sounds explains the different languages



Gods are mans inventions a tool in early cultures to Mark certain people in a tribe to Hold some made up Knowledge given authority or a rubber stamp to be called Shaman or priest to set the rules



later we get to Kings propped up by the priest claiming they were Authorized or endowed by God who pronounces it the priest who invented the gods they become bed fellows hell god heaven none fit the definition of REAL . and you do not get to make up your OWN definition of REAL to make your concepts FIT The Privilege has ended
?
2016-01-09 08:51:08 UTC
These answers are pathetic. People trying to rationalize the definitions and claiming they are biblical.



Hell IS the separation from God, the permanence of that. It is BIBLICAL that hell is the feeling of fire and brimstone.



The answer about Catholicism redefining what we knw about hell to be something else because they think they can reinterpret the bible why Catholicism is not a Christian religion.
?
2016-01-09 08:55:05 UTC
That is the Old Testament idea. Being separate from Paul and Jesus have a different set of consequences.
anonymous
2016-01-09 08:47:45 UTC
This explains it best:



"Live a good life. If there are gods and they are just, then they will not care how devout you have been, but will welcome you based on the virtues you have lived by. If there are gods, but unjust, then you should not want to worship them. If there are no gods, then you will be gone, but...will have lived a noble life that will live on in the memories of your loved ones".
MARGARET
2016-01-09 08:52:55 UTC
No, not exactly. Hell is not a state of mind. Hell is a real physical place just as heaven is. It is located in the spiritual realm which is another dimension from our natural earth.



When the rich man was sent to Hades (Hell) he was down in the depths somewhere and had to look UP TO SEE and TALK TO ABRAHAM. The rich man's tongue was burning and he wanted his brothers warned not to come to that place of torment. (Luke 16:23) SO IT IS DEFINITELY A REAL PLACE.



Jesus died on the Cross to SAVE US HUMANS FROM THIS HORRIBLE FATE but many won't accept His sacrifice so they will be sent to Hell anyway to be punished for not believing in God and not obeying the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ (2 Thessalonians 1: 8 &~ 9)



It won't be God's fault. He has done His utmost to provide a Saviour and Jesus is able to save to the uttermost, those who come to God through Him (Hebrews 7:25)



All humans are born dead (spiritually) in trespasses and sins (those of Adam) and only Christ can make us alive (Ephesians 2: 1 & 5). We are born cut off from God and on our way to hell ALREADY.



That's why Jesus died for us and told us that we MUST be born again of water and Spirit if we want to enter God's kingdom (John 3:3-5)



Because humans are born separated from God, we are born into Satan's kingdom of darkness, but if we repent of our sins and ask Jesus to be our Saviour and be baptized into His death, burial and resurrection (Romans 6: 3-7), God can then crucify our old man (our old Adamic sinful nature) with Christ (Romans 6:6) so that sin no longer has dominion over us (Romans 6:5 & 6) and at that point, God will deliver us OUT OF Satan's kingdom of darkness and translate us INTO the kingdom of the Son of His love (Colossians 1:13).



Then He can save us.



You see Peter said, "Baptism doth now also SAVE US .....through Christ's resurrection" (1 Peter 3:21 )



This prevents us going to hell for eternity



That's why Peter said, "Repent and be baptized every one of you for the remission of your sins and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit (Acts 2:38)



Because Jesus said "He who believes and is baptized SHALL BE SAVED" (Mark 16:16)



So Hell is where all humans are headed from birth unless they do something to change their own destiny by repenting of their sins and accepting Christ as Saviour and all that this entails.
JohnH
2016-01-09 08:46:56 UTC
yes, hell is the separation from God´s love.
okiknowit
2016-01-09 08:44:14 UTC
Darkness is the absence of light, and evil is the absence of God. I don t know about an afterlife, but I do know that you make your own heaven or hell here on earth.
?
2016-01-09 08:45:05 UTC
God knows, dear
anonymous
2016-01-09 08:45:46 UTC
Why don't you watch "The Lazarus Phenomenon" on DVD also FREE over this Internet and SEE your answer?
?
2016-01-09 09:01:01 UTC
Hell is a REAL place.



Read JUDE



GOD IS HOLY and HE WILL JUDGE SIN...
?
2016-01-09 08:54:07 UTC
Hell is a teaching tool. It is a TEMPORARY state of consciousness where souls get to experience the pain and anguish that they caused to others through their words or deeds. They get first-hand experience of the emotional fallout of their actions (which they could not see on earth) – thus they learn what they did right and what they did wrong. This is how we souls learn and grow spiritually. We cannot learn without experience.



This is what people saw during their near-death experiences:



Hell is the pain, anguish, hurt and anger that you have caused others or who suffered as a result of your actions/words to others. Hell is what you have created for yourself within your soul by turning your back on UNCONDITIONAL LOVE, compassion and peace. (Tina)



Those who have stunted their spiritual growth through an undeveloped or misdirected lifestyle, have led a purely self-centered life or have hurt other people, their spiritual environment will reflect something of these realities. A self-centered life on Earth places one in an area of the spirit world with like-minded people who have yet to learn the value of unselfishness for the advancement of the soul. (Nora Spurgin)



The spiritual state of being you have on Earth is the spiritual state you take with you to the world beyond when you die. There is no sudden metamorphosis from an idle person into an active person, from a nonreligious person into a religious person, from a money-centered person into a God-centered person. This is not an automatic thing. Heaven and hell are spiritual states of being. They are not static states but are states in which there can be growth and progress toward ultimate wholeness of being. (Margaret Tweddell)



What people call hell is really a spiritual time-out condition in which souls reflect and work out the things that blocked them from the power of their own light. There is no condemnation in hell, only the outworking of our own misjudgments, mistakes, misalignments, or misappropriations. (Dr. PMH Atwater)



After death people gravitate into homogenous groups according to the rate of their soul's vibrations - much like throwing a small pebble into a threshing machine. It goes into the box that fits its proper size and weight. After death, we are sorted by the high or low vibrations of our soul. Everyone goes where they fit in! High vibrations indicate love and spiritual development, while low vibrations indicate debasement and evil. All one has to do is to LOVE SO UNSELFISHLY that their soul-vibrations rise high enough to fit into heaven. (Arthur Yensen)



The quality of life after death for a suicide is determined by their motive for killing themselves. Those who kill themselves in order to hurt someone, get revenge, or who kill themselves out of hatred for someone else, will haunt the living by being aware of every horrible consequence their suicide had on others. Those who, because of mental illness, confusion, or a terminal illness, take their own life, are allowed many opportunities from God to grow in love just as any other person would who had not committed suicide. (Dr. George Ritchie)



Hell contains people who have been alcoholics or drug addicts, who find these cravings still with them after death. They stay near the Earth to be near alcoholics or drug addicts who are still in the physical body, in order to participate vicariously in the sensations which alcohol and drugs give. They can be helped in the world beyond to clear their soul bodies of these cravings so that they, too, may go on and progress. However, this is a long and tedious process. (Margaret Tweddell)



Physical desires can be carried over into the afterlife but physical desires cannot be satisfied there. This can create a hellish condition for those who have them.



There are earthbound spirits of low vibrations, whom we may regard as devils because they annoy us through mental telepathy. These demons tune in on us through our low vibrations of hate, fear and greed. They can be tuned out with unselfish love, or if necessary be chased away by the stronger spirit of Jesus Christ. (Arthur Yensen)



http://www.near-death.com/experiences/research14.html


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...