Question:
if Islam is peaceful then why do they treat women unequally and beat up homosexuals?
2013-03-23 20:02:20 UTC
Why do they beat up homosexuals?
Why do they treat women unequally?
Why do they kill Muslims who leave Islam?
Why did they spread Islam through war? and not by good deeds?
Ten answers:
Afterbiology1
2013-03-23 20:14:50 UTC
Okay, I want you to listen and listen well.



First off, I'm not Islamic, I'm Jewish.



Your question is fundamentally biased. Have you forgotten about the crusades? Have you forgotten about the Holocaust? The inquisition? Muslims are not the only ones who kill for religious reasons.



Religions do not do any of these things. It's no different from the saying, "Guns don't kill..."



To be honest, the only peaceful religion I can think of is Jainism, a religion which, although I do not follow it, I still have a deep respect for.



UPDATE:

I would like to add that, what the one woman commented is partially true. While she neglects the fact that Islam was spread through warfare (Islamic empires), many people converted to Islam because they preferred it. I can't remember what they are called, but there were Islamic men who would sit atop poles and preach peaceful and tolerant Islam. Islam used to be one of the most intellectual religions in the world as well.
NEoN
2013-03-24 03:03:02 UTC
You have to realize that these issues aren't particular to Islam. I don't know why you single it out. Christianity is also peaceful, Christ was called "The Prince of Peace," but through the centuries there have been countless acts of violence perpetrated by Christians. The same is true of Jews, Hindus, Buddhists, and probably every other sect you can find.



You should also realize that like all those religions, there are different interpretations and groups within them that apply their religious ideologies in different ways. Most Muslims, Christians, Buddhists, Hindus, etc. do not assault homosexuals, abuse women, kill heretics, make war. But, those that do are bound to get a lot of attention because those actions are so far outside the norms of civil behavior.



To take the cliche comparison with Christianity: during the Inquisition, murder of heretics, Jews, and other non-believers was programmatic. Christians killed Jews, Muslims, and other Christians in the decades long assault on the Holy Land during the Crusades. There were unbelievable atrocities committed during the Reformation and the Counter Reformation. Although it's a more recent development, homosexuality is vehemently despised by some Christians, and in some countries it is a crime punishable by death. Uganda's homosexuality laws (which were drafted with the help of a few American Evangelicals) criminalize homosexuality as a capital crime. Wife beating was long permissible by Christianity, and even the way it could or should be done was prescribed. And so on. All the horrors that you ascribe to Islam can also be found in other religions and often for the same reasons.



Because religions rely on sacred and immutable texts and because language is always a little unclear and because people are always willing to be either more or less horrific, you will find that religious people believe and practice the same religion in different ways. Usually, most of the people following a given doctrine act basically according to the cultural norms while a few people take the same doctrine to some really extreme, dark ends. To say that Islam is a peaceful religion misses the point as much as saying that it is a violent religion. It contains both and cannot be one of the other by default. It is a religion and religions are made up of people and people are generally communitarian and peaceful, though they can be incredibly cruel.
?
2013-03-24 08:34:50 UTC
Islam has nearly always been violent!



The violence goes back to a dispute over who had spiritual authority over the Muslim community after the death of the prophet Muhammad in what is called the “fitna” which translates as temptation or trial and caused all the discord within Muslim community.



Shi’ite Muslims believe that authority was vested in his family; the Sunnis look to the sayings and actions of Muhammad as well as the Koran.



The extreme sectarian violence has been brought about by Al-Qaeda Which while being exclusively Sunni deliberately set Shi’ites and Sunnis to kill each other in Iraq. Sadly more muslims die by muslim hands each month than were killed by the invading forces in the war!



Hamas also kills far more muslims than the Israelies ever have!



An average of over thirty five muslims a week were being killed by muslims but in the last few years it has frequently been over a hundred a week!



Whether it is a Danish Cartoon, book of fiction , a snippet of film or some other excuse, Muslims hit the streets around the world rioting, looting, burning and uttering death threats!



Nearly all the muslim countries are seeing muslims attack muslims destroying homes, businesses, infrastructer and targeting women and children particularly showing the extremists must surely be trying to turn muslims into primitives living in caves and mud huts so they can be controlled more easily!
Aliyya
2013-03-24 03:09:21 UTC
I am a true Muslim women and what ever you have said in your question is not true

we have equal rights to men

and a husband is not allowed to hurt his wife

homosexuals are not beaten (we are just told that it is not the right thing like every other religion)

we do not kill if a Muslim wants to convert to another religion

Islam was not spread by war, it was spread by good deeds. Muslims only defended themselves when they were attacked



meadia is just trying to prove something about Islam which is not true
2013-03-24 03:09:36 UTC
Doing the opposite would be injustice and extremism.



Treating women equally = delusion

Beating up homosexuals = straightening them out

Killing Muslims who leave Islam = ending mischief in the land

Spreading Islam though jihad = spreading truth, bring people away from Hellfire.



And actually, Islam did spread through "good deeds" too.
?
2013-03-24 03:10:21 UTC
I keep typing an answer to this question, but I get confused because I think we're talking about Christianity.
Chris the 4th
2013-03-24 03:07:09 UTC
They do not beat up homosexuals silly. They kill them in horrific ways.
Thomas
2013-03-24 03:04:05 UTC
1)Because they are not peaceful.

2)Because they are not peaceful.

3)Because they are not peaceful.

4)Because they are not peaceful and because they are not peaceful.
Carly
2013-03-24 03:07:41 UTC
because they're retards who think there balloons lets blow ourselves up for allah YOUR DOING IT WRONG!!!!!!! HELIUM TANK NOT BOMB
Jem A'dar
2013-03-24 03:03:12 UTC
Why do they blow up buildings?


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...