Question:
why aren't dinosaurs mentioned in the bible?
2007-02-10 23:41:16 UTC
why aren't dinosaurs mentioned in the bible?
26 answers:
pilgrim
2007-02-10 23:56:14 UTC
Chapter 40 of the Book of Job describes a "Behemoth" whose power is in its hips, whose dynamic energy is in the tendons of its belly with a tail (long) like a cedar tree while Chapter 41 of the same book of Job describes a frightful monster described as "Leviathan" with a double jaw, frightful teeth, furrows of scales, unaffected by sword, spear, dart or arrowhead, flames and smoke coming out of its mouth and nostril. I would think the reason why the Bible has no mention of dinosaurs is because the word dinosaur has not been coined until the 18th century.
Freedom
2007-02-11 12:02:39 UTC
Malone's excellent book, Search for the Truth.

Is this a scene from the blockbuster movie, Jurassic Park? It could be, but it isn't. This description, which perfectly fits an Apatosaurus, is a paraphrased description taken from one of the oldest books of the Bible, Job 40:15-24. If dinosaurs have been extinct for 65 million years, how could a writer of the Bible have accurately described the appearance, food, and habitat of this creature?

The vast majority of books on dinosaurs are written from an evolutionary perspective which assumes that the dinosaurs died out 65 million years ago. The leading model for the demise of the dinosaur involves a large asteroid hitting the earth. Yet the most obvious alternative explanation is almost always ignored. Almost all fossils are the remains of creatures buried by water-borne sediment which has subsequently turned to rock. If this is due to the flood of worldwide extent, as the water flowed over all the land surfaces, animals would have been drowned and been buried by massive amounts of rapidly accumulating sediment. It is not all surprising to find a general lack of burial mixing between these very different kinds of animals due to local or ecological grouping.

Genesis 7:2 states that Noah saved two of every representative "kind" of land animal on the ark. Noah would have taken young specimens, not huge, older creatures. Dinosaurs would have emerged from the ark to inhabit an entirely different world. Instead of a warm, mild climate worldwide, they would have found a harsh climate which soon settled into an ice age. If climatic hardships did not cause the dinosaur's extinction, man's tendency to destroy probably did.

In the early 1900's on the Doheny expedition into the Grand Canyon, Indian cave drawings were found which closely resembled a duck-billed dinosaur. Legends from ancient China to ancient England have recorded descriptions of dinosaur-like creatures. The Kuku Yalanji aboriginal people have paintings which look exactly like plesiosaurs. These and other intriguing evidences seem to indicate that perhaps that age of the dinosaurs ended more recently than is commonly taught. Christians do not need to feel foolish about standing on Scripture in their understanding of the world around us. There is ample evidence to support the Biblical record. Evolution serves as the foundation basis for the religions of humanism and atheism. These world views are popular because man, instead of God, decides on rules and moral standards. Creation serves as the foundational basis for Christianity which acknowledges that all things were created by God, that we live in a fallen universe, and that it will be restored to perfection in the future.
cajmarla
2007-02-11 07:47:07 UTC
The Bible is a literary piece and to speak of dinosaurs is to lean towards scientific or factual language. The writers of the Bible, especially in the Old Testament, interpreted reality and were not able to tell facts concerning the origin of the universe, what dinosaurs are, and the evolution of man. Although they are not mentioned in the Bible, dinosaurs have been proven to exist through findings of scientists.
2007-02-11 07:55:28 UTC
As a Christian, I've wondered the same thing, and I've heard some explanations in Sunday school, but they were all pretty lame - real stabs in the dark.



This isn't very mainstream Christian, but I wonder if the section of time we live in (the Age of Adam - or the 'sixth day' as I refer to it) came after other civilizations and ages have passed. There are so many wonders: the pyramids, dinosaurs, ancient mysteries...perhaps these bones are a legacy of a time wiped out - wiped out by God.



If we're heading for the end of this age, then the 'seventh day' is right around the corner. Maybe we'll add the panama canal, the Las Vegas strip, and the concreting of New York to our layer above the dinosaurs.



If your prompted - sound that trumpet - few will care, but someone will hear...
2007-02-11 07:57:37 UTC
Dinosaurs weren't discovered until a few hundred years ago. The people who wrote the Bible were not archaeologists, and if they had been, they were still in the wrong part of the world to know about dinosaurs.

So, you might as well ask, "Why weren't American Bison mentioned in the Bible?" They too were only discovered a few hundred years ago ( by people who write) and were not in the middle east, or Mediterranean lands.
Chaosman
2007-02-11 07:46:47 UTC
Dinosaurs are actually mentioned many many times in the bible on several occasions. This website has lots of information:



http://www.clarifyingchristianity.com/dinos.shtml
AngelsFan
2007-02-11 07:48:38 UTC
Job chapter 40 .Behemoth is a dinosaur.It talks about an animal that eats grass, stands in the river and has a tail the size of a cedar tree.Crocs don't eat grass,hippos and elephants have teeny little tails .but Bronto types have big ones.
2007-02-11 07:45:35 UTC
Because the authors of the Bible thought that the fossils of dinosaurs were "monsters" "dragons", even "demons".
beano™
2007-02-11 07:49:04 UTC
They existed in the time period between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2. A flood took place during that time too, which is why 1:2 says the earth was without form and void. Then God began restoring the earth.
2007-02-11 12:54:21 UTC
Dinosaurs are called behemoths in Job



They are NOT elephants because elephants do not have "tails like a cedar tree".
2007-02-11 07:46:19 UTC
Because dinosaurs had been extinct for millions of years during biblical times, and there were no paleontologists during biblical times.



I mean, they didn't even understand lightning, you're asking way too much of such a primitive society.
allindotcom@sbcglobal.net
2007-02-11 07:44:03 UTC
Dinosaurs existed long before the period when the bible takes place. Oh yeah.......I guess God created them too.
ginger
2007-02-11 07:45:09 UTC
God put dinosaur bones here to fool the non-believers.



Mwahaha.
2007-02-11 07:44:40 UTC
Because the Bible is completely ficticious.
robert f
2007-02-11 07:48:00 UTC
Because it is insignificant and we already have too much that god has given us to try and understand, to tell us about things that don’t matter
frank m
2007-02-11 08:25:07 UTC
it also doesnt mention any animals that live outside the region of arabia/israel like kangaroo for instance.
Odindmar
2007-02-11 07:45:00 UTC
Because they weren't relevant to the story of man.
Debi in LA
2007-02-11 07:44:31 UTC
They are. In Genesus. They mention "monsters" walked the earth. I don't remember the scripture.
o.O
2007-02-11 07:46:16 UTC
they are... i forget the exact book in the bible but there is mentioning of creatures i.e("Leviathan","Behemoth",etc)
2007-02-11 07:43:59 UTC
T-rex ate the dude who was writing about it. Go figure.
2007-02-11 07:46:09 UTC
It wasn't included in the mythology.
free-spirit
2007-02-11 07:44:43 UTC
maybe coz they were not discovered when the bible was written
Help me
2007-02-11 07:44:05 UTC
Because Jesus (Bible) wasn't born yet during that era.
churnin
2007-02-11 07:44:20 UTC
Maybe because god hadn't invented paleontology yet...?
2007-02-11 07:44:53 UTC
God doesn't like sharing the limelight.



AAARRRGGHHH!!!
TruthIsFreedom
2007-02-11 07:47:55 UTC
They are...



Most of us loved reading about dinosaurs at some time in our lives. In 1993, the movie “Jurassic Park” stimulated the public interest in dinosaurs far beyond its previous level. As a result, increasing numbers of people have thought, “Since we have found all these fossils and dinosaur bones, we know dinosaurs existed. How come they are not mentioned in the Bible?”



Actually, dinosaurs are mentioned in the Bible, and we will prove it by doing the following three things:



Examining the Bible’s text and the related scientific facts.

Explaining the accuracy of the Bible.

Exploring what we are taught in school and through the media.





The Bible’s Text

The Bible refers to many the common animals we know today. The list includes lions, wolves, bears, sheep, cattle and dogs along with various kinds of birds, rodents, reptiles, and insects. What is interesting is that this extensive list includes three animals that we no longer recognize. These three are (in the original Hebrew language) tanniyn, b@hemowth (yes, it’s spelled correctly—at least as close as we can get in Roman characters), and livyathan.



Although we alter the spelling of behemoth and Leviathan slightly, we still use those same words in bibles today. However, tanniyn is always translated into another word when we write it in English. Tanniyn occurs 28 times in the Bible and is normally translated “dragon.” It is also translated “serpent,” “sea monster,” “dinosaur,” “great creature,” and “reptile.” Behemoth and Leviathan are relatively specific creatures, perhaps each was a single kind of animal. Tanniyn is a more general term, and it can be thought of as the original version of the word “dinosaur.” The word “dinosaur” was originally coined in 1841, more than three thousand years after the Bible first referred to “Tanniyn.” To make things clearer, we constructed the following table comparing the scientific names with the Biblical names tanniyn, behemoth, and Leviathan.



“Dinosaur” Names, Then and Now

Name and date first written in the Bible Scientific Name (best estimate) and date the name appeared

tanniyn (dragon) before 1400 BC dinosaur 1841 AD

behemoth before 1400 BC brachiosaurus 1903 AD

Leviathan before 1400 BC kronosaurus 1901 AD



How we got these new names is interesting. In 1822, Mary Ann Mantell became the first person to discover and correctly identify a strange bone as part of a large, unknown reptile. Her husband, Dr. Gideon Mantell, later named this creature an “Iguanodon.” From that time forward, these forgotten animals were given names chosen by the people who rediscovered them. Of course, the Bible, written between approximately 1450 BC and 95 AD, does not include any of these names.



Reading the Bible carefully, you will realize that no living creature matches the descriptions of behemoth and Leviathan. However, if you grab your kid’s dinosaur book, you will notice several possible matches for each one. Let’s examine those.



Behemoth has the following attributes according to Job 40:15-24





It “eats grass like an ox.”

It “moves his tail like a cedar.” (In Hebrew, this literally reads, “he lets hang his tail like a cedar.”)

Its “bones are like beams of bronze,

His ribs like bars of iron.”

“He is the first of the ways of God.”

“He lies under the lotus trees,

In a covert of reeds and marsh.”

Some bibles and study bibles will translate the word “behemoth” as “elephant” or “hippopotamus.” Others will put a note at the edge or bottom of the page, stating that behemoth was probably an elephant or a hippopotamus. Although an elephant or hippopotamus can eat grass (or lie in a covert of reeds and marsh), neither an elephant or a hippopotamus has a “tail like a cedar” (that is, a tail like a large, tapered tree trunk). In your kid’s dinosaur book you will find lots of animals that have “tails like a cedar.”



We would expect behemoth to be a large land animal whose bones are like beams of bronze and so forth, so whatever a behemoth is, it is large. A key phrase is “He is the first of the ways of God.” This phrase in the original Hebrew implied that behemoth was the biggest animal created. Although an elephant or a hippopotamus are big, they are less than one-tenth the size of a Brachiosaurus, the largest (complete) dinosaur ever discovered.[1] A Brachiosaurus could therefore easily be described as “the first of the ways of God.”



Comparing all this information to the description in your kid’s dinosaur book, you may come to the conclusion that “behemoth” is not a normal animal, it is a dinosaur—the brachiosaurus. We agree with that conclusion!



Note: Some paleontologists have found fragmentary leg bones, ribs, or vertebrae which they propose belong to “new” sauropods larger than Brachiosaurus. Examples of these include Amphicoelias, Argentinasaurus, Sauroposeidon, Seismosaurus, Supersaurus and Ultrasaurus. There currently is not enough evidence to really determine the size of any of these, and some paleontologists believe that they are merely large examples of known dinosaurs like Brachiosaurus or Diplodocus. In any case, only the “modern scientific name” of behemoth would change. The point would still remain that behemoth refers to a dinosaur, not a “modern animal” like an elephant or hippopotamus.

Leviathan has the following attributes according to Job chapter 41, Psalm 104:25,26 and Isaiah 27:1. This is only a partial listing—just enough to make the point.





“No one is so fierce that he would dare stir him up.”

“Who can open the doors of his face, with his terrible teeth all around?”

“His rows of scales are his pride, shut up tightly as with a seal; one is so near another that no air can come between them; they are joined one to another, they stick together and cannot be parted.”

“His sneezings flash forth light, and his eyes are like the eyelids of the morning. Out of his mouth go burning lights; sparks of fire shoot out. Smoke goes out of his nostrils, as from a boiling pot and burning rushes. His breath kindles coals, and a flame goes out of his mouth.”

“Though the sword reaches him, it cannot avail; nor does spear, dart, or javelin. He regards iron as straw, and bronze as rotten wood. The arrow cannot make him flee; slingstones become like stubble to him. Darts are regarded as straw; he laughs at the threat of javelins.”

“On earth there is nothing like him, which is made without fear.”

Leviathan “played” in the “great and wide sea” (a paraphrase of Psalm 104 verses 25 and 26—get the exact sense by reading them yourself).

Leviathan is a “reptile [a] that is in the sea.” (Isaiah 27:1)

[a] Note: The word translated “reptile” here is the Hebrew word tanniyn. This shows that “Leviathan” was also a “tanniyn” (dragon).



Unlike behemoth, who is huge, Leviathan is ferocious and terrifying. Many references (we have not listed them all) refer to the sea, so Leviathan is probably a sea creature. Although some bibles refer to Leviathan as an alligator or crocodile (and both of these are fierce) neither of these is a sea creature. They like the water, but they spend much of their time on land. Further, the question “Who can open the doors of his face. . . .” implies that nobody can open Leviathan’s jaws. Although an alligator's jaws cannot normally be forced open, a punch to their sensitive snout or poke in eye might startle them enough to release their grip.[2] Although this is a good description of an alligator characteristic, it does not fit perfectly with the description of Leviathan, which in the context of the Bible was supposed to describe an essentially impossible event, and we are not done yet.



The description of the scales is interesting. Several verses describe these great scales. Compared to Leviathan’s armor, iron is like straw and arrows ca not make it flee. Let’s face it, an arrow can do a lot of damage to a crocodile or alligator. This is not a description of either of them—or any living animal we are aware of.



And now for the key ingredient: fire. It is hard to read Job 41:18-21 without realizing the Bible is telling us that Leviathan breathes fire. That alone will eliminate almost every living animal. Yes, there is one animal like that in today’s world. It is called a bombardier beetle. This beetle is a native of Central America, and has a nozzle in its hind end that acts like a little flame thrower. It sprays a high-temperature jet of gas (fueled by hydroquinones and hydrogen peroxide with oxidative enzymes) for protection. Now, if a Central American beetle can do it, so could Leviathan. By the way, crocodiles and alligators are out of the picture on this one, don’t you agree?



Before we leave the topic of fire, there are two more notes you may find interesting:



The history of every culture is filled with stories of fire-breathing dragons. If you think about it, in all the past ages wouldn’t someone have made up a story of a fire-breathing lion or something? Nobody did because the dragon stories are based on truth, and only “dragons” breathed fire. It is easy to imagine Leviathan as a member of the dragon (tanniyn) family. (Plus, Isaiah 27:1 strongly implies this connection.)

Many fossil dinosaur skulls contain unexplained, empty passages. Scientists have not been able to guess the reason for these passages. Would it make sense that some dinosaurs used these passages as “gas tanks” for the combustible mixture used to “breathe fire?” We believe it does.

Comparing all this information to the description in your kid’s dinosaur book, you may come up with the conclusion that Leviathan is a kronosaurus. We have heard (and read) other suggestions, but the kronosaurus is the best match of any known creature to the description of Leviathan.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...