Question:
Jesus said God is a spirit .Seeing Jesus was flesh , was he demonstrating he is not God?
2009-10-08 02:28:02 UTC
John 4:24
24 God is spirit, and his worshipers must worship in spirit and in truth."

Was he tell a half truth ?
Fifteen answers:
Nelson
2009-10-08 15:23:36 UTC
The Trinity is a concept made up by the church's by means of Satan. True christians know there is no trinity. Agape.
♥ SJC ♥
2009-10-09 10:37:32 UTC
What is a spirit? Webster's Dictionary includes in its definition of the word the following: "A supernatural, incorporeal, rational being usu. invisible to human beings but having the power to become visible at will… a being having an incorporeal or immaterial nature." The Hebrew word translated as spirit is ruwach, and it can mean wind, breath, life, anger, unsubstantiality, region of the sky, or spirit of a rational being. The Greek word translated as spirit, pneuma, can mean a current of air, breath, blast, breeze, spirit, soul, vital principle, disposition, angel, demon, or God. All three definitions emphasize that a spirit does not have flesh and bones (Luke 24:39). Similarly, Jesus indicated that the Spirit of God does not have flesh and blood (Matthew 16:17). So, when the Bible says that God is a Spirit, it means that He cannot be seen or touched physically by human beings. As a Spirit, he is an intelligent, supernatural Being who does not have a physical body.



God as a Spirit does not have a body unless He chooses to manifest Himself in a bodily form, which He did in the person of Jesus Christ.



One key verse of Scripture implies that ordinarily God is not visible even to spirit beings unless He chooses to manifest Himself in some way: "God was manifest in the flesh… seen of angels" (I Timothy 3:16). At the least, if God did have some type of spirit body He certainly was not confined to it like other spirit beings are confined to their bodies; for then He would not be truly omnipresent. For example, God's omnipresence means He could have appeared simultaneously to men on earth and to angels in heaven. Also, we must realize that in New Testament times God has chosen to reveal Himself fully through Jesus Christ (Colossians 2:9). There is no possibility of separating God and Jesus, and there is no God visible outside of Jesus.
2017-01-20 03:04:56 UTC
God is a spirit and had no beginning up. He created his Son as a spirit who lived and worked with him for eons of time interior the introduction of the universe. (Colossians a million:15) Then Jesus Christ got here to earth as a human to launch mankind from sin and loss of life in the event that they believed in him and his Father. (John 3:sixteen) After his resurrection he back to heaven as spirit, having sacrificed his human physique, to attend at God's maximum surprising hand till he grew to alter into King of God's Kingdom. there is not any longer something interior the Bible to point Jesus became into God, his very own Father, yet each and every indication that he's not any longer God, yet God's Son.
Trinity
2009-10-10 20:27:41 UTC
No. God can live inside a human and be in human form as well as be a spirit. Have you heard of omnipresence? That is one way to describe God. The human form he took on in this case was Jesus.
true friend
2009-10-08 02:34:37 UTC
You Muslims, you all want to prove Jesus is not God, why don't you all read the Bible completely before askin.



Jesus himself has told many times "He is the Son of God. The Father has sent Him and He speaks by his Father's authority.



Jesus is the ONLY Way, Truth and the Life.
Wendi888
2009-10-08 03:01:10 UTC
Hey, Lone, someone thinks you're a Muslim.



Jesus was certainly confirming that he didn't claim to be his Father, Almighty God. God is not only Jesus' Father and not Jesus himself, God told Moses that "no man can see my face and live". Many, many people saw Jesus while he was on earth.



This scripture is one of many that deny the false belief that God and Jesus are part of a triune god. Jesus told Mary Magdalene that he was going to "my God and your God". He said he came to do not his will but that of his Father. How could they be the same person and not have the same "will"? When someone today thinks or acts like two or more people in the same body we call them schizophrenic.



Jesus admitted that his Father was greater than he was and prayed to his Father before his death that "your (his Father) will, not mine (Jesus) be done". Jesus always gave glory and honor to his Father, not himself. He said God loved the world so much he gave his only-begotten Son so that those exercising faith in him might have everlasting life. Obviously, God created Jesus as he was called the only-begotten Son.



So Jesus, at John 4:24 is telling his followers that they should worship his Father in spirit and truth. One truth is that he and Almighty God are two separate beings.
gismoII
2009-10-08 09:18:34 UTC
The key to understanding these statements is in realizing that Jesus has two natures making Him BOTH God and man. Both are real and neither can be used to negate the other. His human nature is inferior to the Divine & is subject to God leaving the Divine Nature perfectly intact.
Mary Contrary
2009-10-08 02:45:06 UTC
He was born of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary, perfect man and perfect God.
2009-10-08 02:32:45 UTC
No.



Jesus was sinless. He could not lie, or be the sacrifice for our sins, if He WAS lying!



Jesus was refering to the fact of the Father's existance, even though we cannot physically see Him!



Worship comes from faith-NOT from what our 5 senses tell us!
2009-10-08 02:33:02 UTC
jesus is the way, the truth and life
Zero Doctrine
2009-10-08 02:35:28 UTC
Of course he was flesh.



He took a few nails didn't he?
2009-10-09 11:55:49 UTC
Jesus did not begin existence as the baby at Bethlehem. He existed in the spirit realm as the Word of God, who is God (John 1:1-3) and who created everything, meaning he was never created himself. Jesus is not God in his entireity, yet he is fully God. The Holy Spirit is not God in his entireity, yet he is fully God. The one being who is God is not limited to one person, which is why to worship Christ is to worship the Father - not two Gods, but the one and only true God who can act simultaneously and in different places via different persons.



Had not Jesus Christ, even as a man, manifested attributes which belong to God alone? For example, he was clearly omniscient. On several occasions he had read people’s hearts (Mat 9:4 Lk 6:8 Jn 1:47; 2:24-25; 4:17-19). He predicted the details of his own death and resurrection (Mat 16:21) and Peter’s denial and restoration (Lk 22:31-34). And had not the thoughts of his disciples been plain to him, even when he was physically distant from them? (Mk 9:33-37 Lk 9:47). And the expressed doubts of Thomas, even when he was physically absent? (Jn 20:24-29).



Omnipresence is another divine attribute. Although it was manifestly obvious that Jesus was physically present in only one place at a time, on several occasions his language suggested more than that. Talking one night with Nicodemus, he claimed not only to be ‘he who came down from heaven’, but also ‘the Son of Man who is in heaven’ (Jn 3:13). His evident humanity did not prevent him from continuing to operate in that spiritual dimension which had always been his, and to exercise his divine prerogatives there. No less surprising was his promise, even while physically on earth, to be present wherever two or three gathered in his name (Mat 18:20). And it was from physical lips that the apostles heard his promise, ‘And lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age’ (Mat 28:20). Who but God himself could have said all these things, and made such a promise?



If Jesus is God, it cannot be wrong to worship him. The Scriptures teach that not only may worship be given to Christ (as it was, for instance, by Thomas after his resurrection) but that it should be given to him. Such worship is given to him all the time in heaven. ‘Let all the angels worship him’ (Heb 1:6). And they do. Countless myriads surround his throne there, ‘saying with a loud voice, ‘Worthy is the Lamb who was slain to receive power and riches and wisdom and strength and honour and glory and blessing!’ (Rev 5:12). These glorious creatures are joined by his people on earth who exclaim, ‘To him who loved us and washed us from our sins in his own blood, and has made us kings and priests to his God and Father, to him be glory and dominion for ever and ever.’ (Rev 1:5-6)



It is because Christians give to Christ their worship that they are known as those who ‘call on the name of Jesus Christ’ (1 Cor 1:2). They do this because God wills that ‘all should honour the Son just as they honour the Father’, and they cannot forget that ‘he who does not honour the Son does not honour the Father who sent him (v23), and that ‘Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also (1 Jn 2:23). This is why Stephen, during his dying moments, offered prayer to the ascended Christ (Acts 7:59-60). This is why the apostle Paul freely prayed to Christ, calling on others to do the same (Rom 10:12-14 2 Cor 12:8) and held him out as the object of faith (Gal 2:16 Eph 1:15 Phil 3:8)



But there are many men and women who refuse to worship Christ, as well as an innumerable company of angels – better known as demons – who are in open rebellion against him. Christ has a ‘name which is above every name’ (Phil 2:9), but they do not acknowledge it. Yet willingly or unwillingly, the whole creation will join together to give homage to Christ and will call him by his divine name (Phil 2:11). All creatures which have ever existed will be agreed on the truth of the deity of Christ. But far better for us to recognise his authority and claims over us now!



John Chrysostom (c.345-407) wrote an eloquent paragraph on this subject: ‘I do not think of Christ as God alone, or man alone, but both together. For I know he was hungry, and I know that with five loaves he fed five thousand. I know he was thirsty, and I know that he turned water into wine. I know he was carried in a ship, and I know that he walked on the sea. I know that he died, and I know that he raised the dead. I know he was set before Pilate, and I know that he sits with the Father on his throne. I know that he was worshipped by angels, and I know that he was stoned by the Jews. And truly some of these I ascribe to the human and others to the divine natures. For by reason of this he is said to have been both God and Man.’
2009-10-08 02:56:16 UTC
No.



Jesus is God.
Annsan_In_Him
2009-10-09 12:36:56 UTC
Genesis 16:7-13 records how Hagar, who had run away from Abram and Sarai, was commanded by ‘the Angel of the Lord’ to return. It is then made clear that it was Jehovah himself who was speaking to her and she responded by calling him ‘You-are-the-God-who-sees’. The one who was sent by God, and who took a visible form before her, was none other than God himself!



Abraham had a visit from the Angel of the Lord some time later, in the plains of Mamre (Gen 18). The visitor is specifically said to have appeared as a man (v2) but it is also clearly stated that it was the Lord himself (vss 1, 13-14). Abraham recognized this and offered prayer to him (22-23). He stood before a man and addressed him as God!



It is the Angel of the Lord who speaks to Moses from the burning bush and says, “I am the God of your father…” (Ex 3:6), and goes on to reveal his names as “I AM WHO I AM” (14). It is the Angel of the Lord who appears twice in the book of Judges and on each occasion reveals that he is God himself (Jud 6:1-16 13:3,9,22) but his visible form was that of a man. The one they spoke of as ‘a Man of God’ and ‘the Man’ (13,6,10) was God, sent by God! Who else could this have been but the pre-incarnate and eternal Son of God?



The OT takes pains to underline that this person who appeared as a man was not God in any secondary sense. It does this in a variety of ways. For instance, in Jacob’s famous dream of a ladder reaching to heaven, it states: ‘Behold, the LORD stood above it and said, ‘I am the Lord God of Abraham your father.’ (Gen 28:13). The point is made. Jacob saw God. The statement is made without qualification. It is only much later in the narrative, when Jacob is giving his account of another dream, that the identity of God as the Angel of God is made: “Then the Angel of God spoke to me in a dream, saying… ‘I am the God of Bethel…’ (Gen 31:11-13). In this way the idea that the angel he saw was in any way less than God is totally destroyed.



On another occasion Jacob was left alone and a man wrestled with him until the breaking of day (Gen 32:24). The identity of this man is not revealed to us straight away, until Jacob’s own testimony drives it into our minds with considerable force: ‘And Jacob called the name of the place Peniel [i.e. The face of God]; ‘For I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved’ (Gen 32:30). Long before Christ’s incarnation Jacob wrestled with a man who turned out to be God! “Yes, he struggled with the Angel and prevailed; he wept, and sought favour from him. He found him in Bethel, and there he spoke to us – that is, the Lord God of hosts. The Lord is his memorial” (Hosea 12:4-5). “On Mount Sinai God spoke and gave them just ordinances and true laws” (Neh 9:13). The OT baldly states that the voice which spoke was the voice of God. It is not until Stephen’s great speech of defence in the NT that we are specifically told that the voice which gave the law was that of ‘the Angel’ (Acts 7:28). We need never doubt that the Angel of the Lord is Jehovah himself. “The Angel of his presence” is none other than the Lord (Isa 63:7-9).



How does this tie up with the NT assertion that ‘No one has seen God at any time’? (Jn 1:18). The answer is clear when we read the whole of that verse. It reads, ‘No one has seen God at any time. The only begotten Son, who is in the bosom of the Father, he has declared him.’ When John says that nobody has seen God, he means that nobody has seen God the Father. This is confirmed by John 6:46, ‘Not that anyone has seen the Father.’ No one has seen God the Father. None the less, human eyes have seen God! The God they have seen is God the Son. The eternal Son of God appeared many times in human form long before he took to himself a real human nature. [Jesus said] “He who sees me sees him who sent me” and “He who has seen me has seen the Father, so how can you say, ‘Show us the Father’?” (Jn 12:45 14:9)



Be reminded that when Isaiah saw Jehovah in all his glory and prostrated himself in the presence of his overbearing holiness, it was the Lord Jesus Christ that he saw. Compare Isa 6:1-12 with John 12:39-41. The God that he saw in that majestic vision was in the form of a man! But why should God, whose essence is invisible, manifest himself through his Son in human form, even in OT times? The answer is that we may regard Christ’s pre-incarnate appearances in human form as a pledge of his eventual coming among men in human nature – cf Zech 2:10-11 & 13:7 with 1 Pet 1:10-11. The Son of God appearing as a man would be followed by his becoming man.
2009-10-08 02:53:16 UTC
what makes you think God cannot come in the flesh

when it was PROPHESIED that He would and He did.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...