Question:
Is abortion really a sin?
Westerner
2008-09-24 15:35:07 UTC
Now I'm very supportive of abortion. If people have unprotected sex and the woman accidentally gets pregnant, then abortion is the best option.

Now I hate children and babies. The world is overpopulated as it.

Is abortion really considered sin? Is it really considered abortion?
23 answers:
pab
2008-09-24 15:39:16 UTC
though I'm for it, arguing that the world is overpopulated is the worst way to try and support abortion





since the world is overpopulated, can't we just go and kill everyone in some region?
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:59:37 UTC
Yes it is a sin and it is MURDER. How can that child help it if it was created. Why should the child be punished just because the mother is selfish and doesn't want to own up to what she's done?



We are not going to over populate the world, we are not germs on a petri dish and God said to go forth and multiply.



Abortion is a selfish way of a irresponsible women (or girl rather because she's not a woman if she's that irresponsible) getting rid of her problems. A child is special and it's not right that a woman can choose to kill a baby just because she doesn't want anyone else to know it happened or because she doesn't want to deal with it. And for those of you who say "What if she's raped or it's incest." The chance of that happening is less than 1%. That is a fact, look it up.



The child inside of a woman is NOT part of her body. It is a fact that during pregnancy that the woman's blood and the babies blood NEVER mix during pregnancy. Second, the blood type of a mother may be A but the blood type of the child could be B. If the child is part of the mothers body then why are there 2 different blood types. Third, the mother can not control what the baby does in her body. She can not will the child to move or kick. So for those of you who say "It's my body, I'll do what I want with it." It's not your body, it's the babies body. You are the one that was stupid enough to have an unwanted pregnancy but that does not give you the right to murder an innocent child.
anonymous
2008-09-25 00:07:36 UTC
The 6th Commandment says "You shall not murder." Murder is the taking of an innocent life. Abortion kills a child. Nobody has the right to murder babies just because they are 3 inches on the wrong side of his or her mothers tummy. The world is not overpopulated. Just take a drive in the country and you will see we have plenty of land for everyone. Sin is violation of God's law. Murdering innocent babies who were conceived by sinful fornicating parents is doubly evil.
Belle16
2008-09-24 22:57:11 UTC
Yes. If you are Christian, and you believe in our loving God, then you understand that every life is precious, and we do not have the right to decide who should live and who should die. Sexuality is a gift from God, as are children, and if anyone calls a pregnancy an "accident", then they do not realize the blessing that children are. If you don't want any "accidents" then don't have sex!



Now, obviously, if you are not a Christian, then you need to check with your own faith group on whether or not it is a sin. But I believe that for most faiths, it is considered murder: the taking of a human life.



If someone is not religious, then their moral compass will be different, and these views will not apply. But one who calls themselves religious needs to consider that we cannot pick and choose which of our faiths' beliefs we will abide by, like you pick food at a salad bar. Either you believe or you don't; and if you're not sure, then you can pray for enlightenment.



I hope someday you revise your hatred of children and babies. That is a sad place to live in.
AdoreHim
2008-09-24 22:49:33 UTC
You are VERY sick. A woman does not accidentally have sex so she does not accidentally get pregnant. Abortion is the best option, when you don't want a baby? HOW ABOUT ADOPTION. If you decided after the birth of your child, that you did not really want them, and you killed them, you would be up for murder. However when that baby is being grown in the womb of a woman- it is a choice? Come on now
Pocketchange
2008-09-24 23:09:55 UTC
Of course abortion is a sin, it is murder. Furthermore, you are the most shallow, arrogant person I have ever heard from. What if your parents had of aborted you? Were you accidental? Of course not! The choice is not rather to have sex and create a human life, the choice is rather or not to take your pants off.
?
2008-09-24 22:43:06 UTC
Ah, you silly troll.



Abortion should be extremely rare, and should NOT be a method of birth control...it can be quite emotionally stressful for the parents.



Honestly, if you're mature enough to have sex, you should know the proper methods of protection. I mean, come on, people. You can get condoms for a few bucks. You can even get them for free in schools, some shelters, etc.



However, a woman's body belongs to her, and we shouldn't force anybody to carry a fetus when they don't want to. One, the thought of controlling other people like that is rather disgusting to me. Two, illegal abortion would only lead to coathanger abortion - which is awful and dangerous.



If my roomie's eleven-year-old niece got raped and got pregnant...of course abortion would be the right choice there.



Third-tremester abortions should always be illegal, though. When a fetus has a brain and a nervous system - I think killing it is murder.
anonymous
2008-09-24 23:23:15 UTC
Yes, it is considered a sin by Christians, but who cares?

I hate when people ask "What if you would have been aborted?"

Well then I wouldn't even know would I?
tomato soup
2008-09-24 23:03:01 UTC
I was raised Catholic and was taught that in order for something to be a sin you had know something was wrong and do it anyway.



If you KNOW that abortion is a sin and do it anyway then, yes it is a sin.
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:49:22 UTC
"If people have unprotected sex and the woman accidentally gets pregnant, then abortion is the best option."

NO ONE I know is in favour of such as you portray.



Tell me, me and all my girls, how many babies did you adopt last year?

Tell me, me and all my girls, how many young unmarried mothers did you help last year?



Kid, if you and all your ignorant little friends were more inclined to educate girls on how they become pregnant, as well as HOW to avoid it by using condoms or birth control pills, there would be less unplanned pregnancies BUT you and your kind can only come up with ONE way, that defies logic and prevailing evidence to it working, and that is abstinence.

It's almost time y'all started dealing with reality, don't you think OR are you too frightened of your talking-donkey-riding invisible hairy monster in the sky?

Woo-Woo.

~
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:40:36 UTC
Pro 6:16 ¶ These six [things] doth the LORD hate: yea, seven [are] an abomination unto him:





Pro 6:17 A proud look, a lying tongue, and hands that shed innocent blood,





Pro 6:18 An heart that deviseth wicked imaginations, feet that be swift in running to mischief,





Pro 6:19 A false witness [that] speaketh lies, and he that soweth discord among brethren.
dreamgirl
2008-09-24 22:39:58 UTC
I don't know if abortion is REALLY a sin or not. Sometimes it is necessary. I'm not sure what I feel about it. But don't hate the kids. They didn't ask to be here.
Passionately Curious
2008-09-24 22:45:16 UTC
If the woman doesn't want to get pregnant then she shouldn't be having sex in the first place.



Overpopulation is pathetic justification for abortion, why not go out and kill everyone in your town. The population will certainly decrease.



"Is abortion really considered sin? Is it really considered abortion?"

Yes and Yes.

Yes, abortion is really considered a sin.

Yes, abortion is really considered abortion. (duh)
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:41:36 UTC
Nope - I don't believe the Bible calls abortion a sin. I'm a Christian and I'm pro-choice.
laughin_giggle477
2008-09-24 23:05:31 UTC
yes,its cold blood murder. if the woman doesnt want the baby give it up for adoption!!!
Illuminator
2008-09-24 22:43:16 UTC
We know what the word “sacrifice” means. It means the surrender of something precious to the god in whom a person believes. Sacrifices have been part of world religions since the dawn of recorded history. Without exception, the deities of all the religions of the ancient world demanded sacrifices in their honor. The Egyptians and Babylonians, the Greeks and Romans, the deities of pre-Christian India and of the continent of Africa required that their adherents offer what we call sacrifices in their name.



What is less well known, however, is that these religions also required the sacrifice of children as an oblation and even as a condition, for obtaining blessings from the gods. We read in the Office of Readings for today’s Divine Office that the Lord spoke through the prophet Jeremiah, charging the Jews of imitating the pagans in their practice of child homicide. Said the Lord, “They have built high places for Baal to immolate their sons in fire as holocausts to Baal: such a thing as I neither commanded nor spoke of, nor did it ever enter my mind.”



As we read statements like foregoing, we ask ourselves: how could human beings be so deluded as to seriously believe that their gods required human sacrifice as a condition for receiving divine favors? The key word is “deluded.” Thirty years of teaching comparative religion has taught me that there is no limit to the irrational, indeed insane, practices that religious mythology will not put into practice as a mandate from the deities in whom they believed. Thus we read in the history of the Aztecs in South America before Columbus that they would kill up to ten thousand children on a major feastday in honor of one of their gods. Although seldom mentioned, infanticide as a religious ritual was practiced in India before its colonization by Great Britain.



We return to the theses that should be explored far beyond the time we can give it in this conference. Abortion as the widespread practice that it has become today is incredibly a religious practice. It is inspired by the evil spirits who, in Christian terms, were and are the malignant deities of paganism. These deities, often goddesses, demanded the sacrifice of children to be propitiated. Unless children were killed and offered to these gods, they would avenge their anger against the people in the most devastating ways.

http://www.therealpresence.org/archives/Abortion_Euthanasia/Abortion_Euthanasia_005.htm



The future of the human race depends on the Catholic Church’s teaching on abortion. This is the statement I wish to prove in this lecture.



Before we go any further in my presentation, let me first explain what I mean.



I mean that the survival of the human race depends finally on the acceptance of the Catholic Church’s two thousand years’ teaching that the killing of unborn children is murder.

http://www.therealpresence.org/archives/Abortion_Euthanasia/Abortion_Euthanasia_007.htm



In my judgment abortion and euthanasia are at the heart of the crisis that is plaguing and destroying the modern world. I do not intend to address the issue of defending the rights of the unborn or the aged in this discourse. They obviously have these rights, and abortion and euthanasia are serious crimes against the rights of unborn children, the aged and terminally ill. Rather, our focus will be on the rights of God that are being violated by the crimes of abortion and euthanasia in the most homicidal century in human history.



I would like to address myself to two areas of our subject. First, to the sanctity of human life and then to the relationship between chastity and charity to the fifth commandment of the divine decalogue.



When God became man in the person of Jesus Christ and took human flesh of his mother Mary, he introduced an understanding of human life that was simply unknown or ignored in the pagan Roman Empire into which Jesus Christ was born. Abortion and infanticide were legalized in Roman law in the first century of the Christian era. It was assumed that the aged and the terminally ill would be destroyed.



All the political means being used in the modern world to protect the life of the unborn and the aged and terminally ill in our own country today are inadequate to meet the crisis we are facing. America is becoming a paganized nation. What Christ did was to introduce an entirely new meaning to human life. Because Jesus Christ raised natural human life to a supernatural level, human life is holy and human life is sacred. Human life belongs to God and the rights of God are being violated by abortion and euthanasia. And once we act upon that principle of our Christian, Catholic Faith, then the worldwide homicide that we are witnessing today will be stopped. It is up to us to stem the tide of the massive murder in the modern world.



http://www.therealpresence.org/archives/Abortion_Euthanasia/Abortion_Euthanasia_010.htm
sondra
2008-09-24 22:53:09 UTC
abortion is murder and murder is a sin.
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:41:47 UTC
No such thing as sin.
Creepy Man2
2008-09-24 22:39:52 UTC
Is murder a sin?
Tabitha
2008-09-24 22:52:31 UTC
Big time.
anonymous
2008-09-24 22:43:43 UTC
yes it is! coz ure killing a human being!
Ghost♂
2008-09-24 22:39:10 UTC
No, its not a sin.
mg© - anti VT™ MG AM© Fundi4Life
2008-09-24 22:38:25 UTC
yes it is


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...