Question:
Is Islam truly divine or is it another "expert's craft"?
Damystic
2009-10-05 16:57:41 UTC
I do not mean to vex Muslims but has anyone noticed there is nothing new in Islam unlike Christianity, Buddhism Hinduism and others. Take a look at the rosary which was adopted by the Muslims. 95% of the quran is a "photo-copy" of Judaism, they are strikingly similar. The way Muslims pray is actually the same way pagan's pray in the past(VERY SIMILAR TO THE BAAL WORSHIPERS). Islam adopts all the stories in the bible but apart from Prophet Mohammad nothing makes them unique. I'm starting to believe Islam "lifted" massively from the law of Moses and the bible and called it the Quran which was edited by Mohammad and his gang. Besides the quran says so little about the heroes and may be heroines of Islam yet so much about the heroes of the bible. why?
Ten answers:
2009-10-05 17:07:52 UTC
It was the different times the two pieces were written. Islam is a a bunch of the monotheistic principles of the Jewish and Christan religions. Mohammad wasn't happy with the pagan worshiping money hungry state of his homeland so started this religious ideals with the best of intentions. As for the anti-hero worship in the Qua ran that is Mohammad's doing as well he didn't want idol worship or saint worship in Islam like in Catholicism. He found it annoying that people prayed under the statues of Jesus because they warped his image into a straight haired white guy. Imagery is not allowed of Mohammad or any imagery are allowed in any mosque.
no1home2day
2009-10-05 17:14:39 UTC
Islam disagrees with the Bible in some very important and basic doctrinal issues.



Both in logic as well as in law, "historical precedent" means that the burden of proof rests on those who set forth new theories and not on those whose ideas have already been verified. The old tests the new. The already established authority judges any new claims to authority.



Since Islam came along many centuries after Christianity, Islam has the burden of proof and not Christianity. The Bible tests and judges the Qur'an. When the Bible and The Qur'an contradict each other, the Bible must logically be given first place as the older authority. The Qur'an is in error until it proves itself.



Muslims violate the principle of historical precedent by asserting that Islam does not have the burden of proof and that the Qur'an judges the Bible.
2009-10-05 17:39:11 UTC
Islam is a fraudulent "religion" in my opinion. I am entitled to my opinion and you asked a legitimate question (queue in the TD bandits), so I will give a legitimate answer. Islam figured one thing right...all of the top 3 Abrahamic faiths are violent, oppressive to women, and restrictive. Islam took this one step further by ensuring that women's rights were clearly outlined IN the actual "holy" book they follow, the koran. Book 4 deals exclusively all with women and how they should be beaten, restricted and their "rights", instead of the bits and pieces in this book that book, mentioned about women in the bible and torah.



I think Muhammad was an evil genius. He saw that through violence, complete control of women and using them almost exclusively for reproduction only at a man's whims, over time, Islam would take over entire regions. It remains one of the largest religions that still condone and encourage polygamy, which usually appeals to men of questionable character. Women are virtual chattel in the Islamic world, they hold no ritual divinity or right, as in Christianity, the virgin mother at least is recognized. Chastity is valued above all, because dominating and oppressing and control over a woman is so vital to Mohammad's vision and the successful spread of Islam.



Women are the key, and totally taking their power away in my opinion, has made Islam what it is. Sure, sure...there are plenty of other factors, but I think women and the taking of their power is the most relevant. Think of this...at least in places where Christian missionaries touched foot and overtook, like Vanuatu and Papua New Guinea for example, the people still hold onto old customs and traditions. Look at places like Iran, Iraq (ancient Persia was NOT Islamic!!!) and Egypt. What the heck happened there? They destroyed EVERYTHING having to do with any other religion or popular belief system. Ancient cities like Ur, they destroyed. The ziggurats, they destroyed. In persia long ago, only whores wore veils to cover their faces, now look at them. Does anyone know how much of antiquity that Muslim conquerors have destroyed? Countless ancient artifacts are forever gone, they routinely cordon off or destroy ancient temples found in remote desert in Saudi Arabia and allow no archaeologists access to study. There are of course, rigid muslims and lax muslims like any other belief, but Islam encourages extremism due to it's tenets and fundamentals.
MB
2009-10-05 17:08:02 UTC
Muslim prayer > Prostration can be found in OT. Jesus also prostrated to god NT



Islaam does not make a claim to be a complete new set of principles, rather it is the most improvised of the Abrahamic faiths...



Muslims believe Muhammad (saw) was the "Comforter" and the Prophet in Deuteronomy.



This Quran is not such as can be produced by other than Allah; on the contrary it is a confirmation of (revelations) that went before it, and a fuller explanation of the Book (10:37 AYA/38 MP).
dinesh.theboss
2009-10-05 20:00:24 UTC
What are all of u guys fussing about? All ur Judaism, Christianity, Islam are all lifted from the Persian religion Zoroastrianism. Every single doctrine, teachings, etc etc are all Prophet Zarathustra's teaching. So stop fooling your self that your own religion is great and respect other religions as well.
2009-10-05 17:09:17 UTC
wow......ok where do we begin.........first of all your understanding of Islam is very primitive, you need to study much more before you ask questions lol Islam, never claimed to be a 'new' religon, infact it claims to be a correction of mistakes in past religons due to human interfention such as lies and loss of knowledge to Judaism adn Christianity.



Did you even know Muslims believe in the bible and torah??



seek more knowledge.



peace.
2009-10-05 18:04:40 UTC
Hahahaha. No. Christianity isn't unique either. There is very little that is new in any religion.
...
2009-10-05 17:01:50 UTC
Maybe the others are just slightly wrong? I'm not God, I don't know these things.
♥ terry g ♥
2009-10-05 17:01:41 UTC
Depends on who you ask. I believe it's truly divine. Most people here will disagree.
2009-10-05 18:13:39 UTC
''Truly the religion in Allah's sight is a Islam, [Qura'n]


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...