Walid Sahib – you are an old man – At this ripe age realize how you have spent your life. Instead of writing questions on other religions, question yourself. When your prophet Muhammad was your age, he married and had sex with a 10 year old girl called Ayesha, who was probably your grand daughter’s age.
Do you think that was right. Would you permit any person of your age to marry your grand daughter ? Should you revere such a pedophile prophet ? Read the following below, then argue with yourself, realize the truth, convert out of Islam and die in dignity.
MUSLIMS SAY THAT THIS IS NOT TRUE - THIS IS A MISCONCEPTION SPREAD BY NON MUSLIMS
Muslims say that these are not misconceptions spread by non muslims.
My Answer - Your 6 major books on Hadiths actually state this clearly.
A – Sahih bukhari Book–Most Muslims view this 9 volume Book as their most trusted collection of Hadith and it has been called "The most authentic book after the Qur'an. Sahih Bukhari is the work of over 16 and covers almost all aspects of life in providing proper guidance of Islam. Before writing any Hadith in this book the author asked guidance from Allah. Then he would do the necessary research and investigation, observing if the particular Hadith fits in to his strict criteria of authenticity and if he is sure that the Hadith is authentic, he wrote it in the book.
B – Sahih muslim Book - It is the second most famous Hadith collection among Muslims and it is considered as the most authentic book of Hadith after Sahih Al-Bukhari. Each report in this collection was checked for compatibility with the Qur'an. , and the veracity of the chain of reporters had to be painstakingly established. But you mischeviously say that this book contradicts the Koran.
C - Sunan abu da'ud book – Another part of this series of 6 books, but some Muslims say that some Hadiths here are unauthentic, which makes his book different from Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim. In other words, all Muslims universally ( with 1 exception – Mr Constant ) consider them authentic.
MUSLIMS SAY THAT THE QURAN MAKES NO REFERENCE TO THIS ACT
Muslims say that there is no part said in the Qura'an that a minor girl can be married with major man. Any statement which is contradicting to Qura'an can not be taken as a preferred one.
My Answer - The Koran did not specifically say that Muhamad DID NOT MARRY Ayesha, so if another extremely Holy Book says so, there is no contradiction.
A CHILD REACHING PUBERTY –
Muslims say – “Can any body prove that a 9-10 year girl old girl can not reach to her maturity age. Prove it scientificaly?”
Muslims also say “It’s a fact that female menstruation in hot climates starts much earlier than in cold climates, so females in Arabia matured as early as 8 or 9; they also aged earlier than other women.”
My Answer - . So what if a kid matures early. The thought of a 55 year old man becoming aroused by a 10 year old child is one of the most disturbing thoughts that makes us cringe as it reminds us of pedophilia and the most despicable people.
THE PROPHETS MARRIAGE TO A 40 YEAR OLD LADY –
Muslims say “ pedophile has no meaning as when Prophet Muhammad was 25 years old, his first marriage was with a 40 years lady.”
My Answer : That is an illogical argument as most pedophiles are married to mature ladies.
MARRYING VERSUS RAPING A 10 YEAR OLD GIRL. –
Some Muslims make this shocking statement regularly - that "marrying a ten year old girl is better or raping a 10 year old girl."
My Answer : That is a shameful argument – I should rest my case here itself, but there is more to come.
TRAVELLING BACK 1400 YEARS IN TIME
Muslim say “social traditions …….. considered Arab females as women as soon as their menstrual cycles began. The custom was to give daughters in marriage at that age.”
My Answer : Many Muslims have this argument to state that what the Prophet did was custom. But does a prophet not need to have a higher standard. Is a Prophet not supposed to improve the world ? What’s the point in being a Prophet then ?
AISHA WAS EARLIER MARRIED TO AN INFIDEL
Muslims say “It’s a neglected fact that before she was married to Muhammad, `A’ishah had been engaged to an infidel, Jubair ibn Mus’ab ibn Ady. Her fiancé broke the engagement on the basis of religious difference.So her father, Abu Bakr, agreed to give her hand in marriage to the Prophet.”
My Answer – …………just because she her marriage to an infidel broke up ? So was the Prophet doing her a favour ?
ESCAPIST STATEMENTS LIKE AISHA WAS A LEARNED WOMAN IN ISLAMIC HISTORY
Muslims say Aisha came from a learned house, had a young, intelligent, receptive mind, later she taught thousands of men worldwide, and is considered among the most prominent Islamic scholars.
My Answer – That fact is irrelevant to Child marriage. Muslims have to make unessary statements so that they can escape from discussing this point.
Most Muslims will make statements about other Gods and Goddesses instead of defending the prophet – because they know they cannot defend him.
TO WRAP IT ALL UP
I have a feeling that you are uncomfortably aware of what your prophet was up to so you will put up wrong arguments. This is the habit of Muslim apologists, because, in their heart of hearts, they know the sick truth.