What many atheists call "evidence" is not the same as what makes them atheists. The reason for this is that people will usually accept what is in agreement with their world view, and evidence has no such bias.
This is true of pretty much every philosophical stance, so ultimately, no matter what evidence you or anyone presents, a person must make up their mind and heart.
All I can do is present some of the reasons why people acknowledge the existence of God, specifically in the Creator of all things, and point out some of the problems with atheism.
People believe in God because God makes himself known through his works. Also, because just like a house is constructed by someone, the one who constructed all things is God. Thirdly, a real, ultimate Creator, by definition, has to be uncreated, so there must be only one.
The God of the Bible recommends himself to be the Creator because of consistent fulfillment of prophecy. Secondly, every few months a discovery in science or archeology is made that corroborates some aspect of the Bible's account. Third, the morality of the Bible's commands about how to live our lives works for everyone - respect for life, respect for property, respect for reproductive powers, respect for truth, and most of all, to put God's service in the center of our lives.
There is a lot of evil in this world, that is, a lot of self-destructive, selfish, violent, senseless behavior, and this is a puzzle in the minds of many of the most dyed-in-the-wool evolutionist/atheists, because they would expect that all of these "millions and billions of years of evolution" would result in a more productive behavior pattern. But it is caused by the evil in many humans, and because, right now, Satan is the ruler and god of this world. John 14:30; 2 Corinthians 4:3-4 God our Creator, because he is a just God, has a plan to get rid of the evil in the world, and undo the evil that has been done.
Think about that: Why don't people love one another, without God? Why is there war and crime and hunger in a world of plenty and lots of scientific discovery? It is not about the man made aspects of some religions, it is about man needing God to guide their roadway. They are doing a pretty bad job of it now.
Fear of punishment, and faith in that punishment does not lead a believer in God to do right. God is not a slave driver, making you do what you don't want to do. If it is in your heart to want truth and righteousness and love, you will be drawn to the true God.
Also, agnostics do not want to commit themselves to either one or the other position. The problem with that is that the agnostic does not obligate him or herself to being accountable to God with the way that they live their lives, but this stance would not please the God who in their mind may or may not be there.
Suppose your child said "I am not sure whether or not I love you. I am not even sure that you are my parent- I don't remember being born." This might give you some idea of how our Creator might feel about this position.
The Bible says "If you search for him, he will let himself be found by you."
2 Chronicles 15:2, also James 4:7-8
This search has to be honest and sincere, not like the so-called experiments conducted by scientists, as though God is some kind of phenomenon. In this way, the agnostic and the atheist might find the real reason why faith in God will never die.
Acceptance of the existence of an absolute example - an intelligent, purposeful Creator, can move one to believe that all humans are brothers and sisters. Acceptance of an absolute unimpeachable moral code, one which includes mercy and compassion, but which no one can influence with bribery or threats, can move one to believe that we are obligated to treat one another with love and respect. The God of the Bible sent his Son to provide a visual example, and to provide a way of salvation, eventually, from the sinful tendencies with which we still find ourselves. This makes moral sin something to avoid, which, again, atheism in its basic philosophy does not completely condemn.
Atheists sometimes point to people who are atheists and who are moral. It should also be noted that atheism does not make them moral. There are atheists who are very amoral but who are still atheists. If a Christian is amoral, they are acting against the teaching that they apparently accepted at some point. Jesus himself said repeatedly that if someone comes to him saying "Lord,Lord" but does not do the will of his Father, he will reject them. Matthew 7:21; Luke 6:46
Greed, passion, jealousy, pride, ambition, pain, fear - I could go on and on, and all of these at one time or another will induce humans to do stupid, self-destructive, and ILLOGICAL things. Atheists say that their choices are completely based on reasoning and science and logic, but humans have a tendency to lie to themselves, too, and their choices too frequently turn out to be based on any one of these kinds of things.
Now there is an additional statistic, that atheists are more likely to commit suicide or be depressed or abuse drugs. http://psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/appi.ajp.161.12.2303
http://www.adherents.com/misc/religion_suicide.html
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/10/131003093041.htm
So we have incentive to do better morally in our lives, by our acceptance and love for our Creator, and by the example set by Jesus Christ.
Sometimes atheists will point to certain church practices and history as proof that God would not exist in the midst of this confusion. But what they are doing is blaming God for the works of humans. Despite having the scriptures, many churches and religions still teach and practice ungodly and non-Christian doctrines, which make that worship in vain.
It is logical that the evil of the world will one day be done away with by the power of a just Creator.
By the way, creationism is NOT a common belief of all those who accept the existence of a Creator - it is a term that was appropriated and defined by specific religious groups as including the unscriptural belief that the earth or the universe was created in six 24-hour days.The Bible, specifically the first two chapters, define the word "day" as 12 hours, 24 hours, or the creative period. This indicates that the word day is a fixed period of time, not necessarily 24 hours long.
Just because a Creator of the universe cannot be seen does not deny his existence, because we don't see gravity, or the wind, or electricity, but we know that they exist, because we see their effects. Similarly, when we see lives radically changing for the better because of a new found faith in a Creator, we are seeing the effects of God in their lives. I have seen this many, many times, and no atheist can deny that this happens.
The truth is that there is no proof that there is no intelligent Creator - and the tremendous complexity and interconnectedness of our existence strongly indicate that one does. Atheists generally do not want to talk about beginnings or of finding final answers to important questions, which is the whole point of it all. Who am I? What am I? Where did I come from? Where am I going? Is this life all there is? We could give our opinion about these questions, but opinions are not answers.
It is true that most great scientists in history believed that the earth was created.
To insist that scientific methodology was conceived only in the last 300 years is unreasonable, especially in view of our knowledge of ancient cultures and their accomplishments - they were not all ignorant deluded illiterate goat herders.
It is also true that the modern scientist accepts that at some point in the distant past, the universe began to exist.
This fact brings Kalam's Cosmological Argument into play. (Google it)
It is also true that an alternate cause of the universe is intelligent rather than a mindless force. The question then is, is the ultimate source of that existence someTHING or someONE -- that is, a mindless random source, or an intelligent one?
Because information has never resulted from randomness, the intelligent answer is superior.
Therefore, there exists an intelligent, powerful, purpose-oriented, uncreated Creator as the one true God.