Question:
My religion requires fasting, but is it healthy for me?
Julia Nannery
2012-03-27 17:07:33 UTC
I'm still young, so I don't "have" to fast but I want to take part in my religion. However, I do take medicine for depression. I'd like to see how long I can go, fasting during the month that my parents fast for, but I was just going to try one week at first. I am allowed to drink anything and take vitamins and such, but I'm just not sure if it's healthy.
Ten answers:
2012-03-27 17:10:18 UTC
Ask your doctor.
Slick
2012-03-28 00:14:36 UTC
Going without food for too long will obviously kill you. The idea behind fasting is not to see how long you can go without food. God would not want you to do anything that would damage your body. They say that Christ fasted for 40 days and 40 nights but he was the son of God and had powers and abilities that we don't fully understand.



Why don't you try fasting for a single day? Who says that you have to fast for many days in a row? You are taking medication for depression so the other thing is knowing how your body will react if you take the medication and are not actually eating.



It's ok if you don't fast. God knows what's in your heart even if no one else does. He knows that you are sincere in your belief. What is in your heart is more important than anything. Sometimes we are made less able because of different difficulties. This does not diminish your importance.



God loves you no matter what you are capable of. If your heart is right before him then you have nothing to fear.



Be at peace.
Matt
2012-03-28 00:15:17 UTC
I assume you are a Muslim, since Jews don't fast for a full month. It is my understanding that the fast is daylight only, and small meals are allowed in the evening. Considering how many people partake in this type of fast, the overwhelming evidence is that it will not harm your body. You probably need to be less active during the month, but you should be able to survive it with no problem.
Tybee
2012-03-28 00:15:02 UTC
My assumption is your religion is Christianity. If so, it does not require fasting if it is detrimental to your health.



if you're talking about some other religion, I have no idea.
bird
2012-03-28 00:11:28 UTC
so where is god when you are depressed? shouldn't loving god make you less depressed? personally i would never take another antidepressant, just smoke some weed and drink some beer, at least you have an idea of the long term effects of these drugs.
Biblical
2012-03-28 00:23:37 UTC
FASTING is a practice common to many of the world’s religions, including Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam, Jainism, and Judaism. Many people believe that abstaining from food for a certain period of time draws one closer to God.

What does God’s Word, the Bible, have to say on this subject?



In Bible times, people fasted for various reasons that met with divine approval. Some fasted to express extreme sorrow or repentance for sins (1 Samuel 7:4-6), to implore God’s favor or seek his guidance (Judges 20:26-28; Luke 2:36, 37), or to sharpen one’s concentration while meditating.—Matthew 4:1, 2.

The Bible, however, also refers to fasts that God did not view with favor. King Saul fasted before consulting a spirit medium. (Leviticus 20:6; 1 Samuel 28:20) Wicked people, such as Jezebel as well as the fanatics who planned to kill the apostle Paul, proclaimed fasts. (1 Kings 21:7-12; Acts 23:12-14)

The Pharisees were well-known for their regular fasting. (Mark 2:18) Yet, they were condemned by Jesus, and they failed to impress God. (Matthew 6:16; Luke 18:12) Likewise, Jehovah ignored the fasts of certain Israelites because of their bad conduct and wrong motives.—Jeremiah 14:12.



These examples show that it is not the act of fasting in itself that pleases God. However, many sincere servants of God who did fast met with divine approval. So should Christians fast?



Although Jesus did fast as the Law required, he was not known for this practice. He told his disciples how they were to act if they chose to fast, but he never commanded that they fast. (Matthew 6:16-18; 9:14)

Why, then, did Jesus say that his disciples would fast after his death? (Matthew 9:15) This was not a command. Jesus’ words simply suggest that at his death his disciples would feel deep sorrow and would lose the desire to eat.



Two Biblical accounts of early Christians who did fast show that if with good motive a person chooses to abstain from food, this is acceptable to God. (Acts 13:2, 3; 14:23)



**Christians are under no obligation to fast. Yet, a person who chooses to do so should be alert to certain dangers.



One pitfall to avoid regarding fasting is self-righteousness. The Bible warns against adopting “mock humility.” (Colossians 2:20-23) Jesus’ illustration of the proud Pharisee who felt morally superior to others because of his regular fasting leaves no doubt that God rejects such an attitude.—Luke 18:9-14.

It would also be a mistake to publicize the fact that you fast or to fast because another person tells you to do so. According to Matthew 6:16-18, Jesus counseled that fasting should be a private matter, between you and God, and that you should not announce it to others.



One should never think that fasting somehow compensates for sinning. To be acceptable to God, a fast must be accompanied by obedience to his laws. (Isaiah 58:3-7) Heartfelt repentance, not the act of fasting itself, is what leads to the forgiveness of sins. (Joel 2:12, 13) The Bible emphasizes that we receive forgiveness by God’s undeserved kindness expressed through the sacrifice of Christ. It is impossible to earn forgiveness through any works, including fasting.—Romans 3:24, 27, 28; Galatians 2:16; Ephesians 2:8, 9.



Isaiah 58:3 illustrates another common error. The Israelites suggested that Jehovah (Psalm 83:18) owed them something in return for their fasting, as if by fasting, they were doing God a favor. They asked: “For what reason did we fast and you did not see, and did we afflict our soul and you would take no note?” Many today likewise think that because of their fasting, they can expect God to perform some favor for them in return. May we never imitate such a disrespectful and unscriptural attitude!

Others believe that it is possible to earn merit by submitting the body to discomfort through fasting, whipping themselves, or the like. God’s Word condemns this notion, showing that “a severe treatment of the body” is “of no value in combating” wrong desires.—Colossians 2:20-23.



Fasting is not obligatory; nor is it wrong. It may be beneficial in some circumstances if the dangers mentioned above are avoided. Fasting, however, is not the focus of acceptable worship. Jehovah God is “the happy God,” and he wants his servants to be happy. (1 Timothy 1:11) His own Word says: “There is nothing better for them than . . . that every man should eat and indeed drink and see good for all his hard work. It is the gift of God.”—Ecclesiastes 3:12, 13.
?
2012-03-28 00:13:00 UTC
Religion is bad for your health
2012-03-28 00:11:35 UTC
Come to Jesus. He will free you from your religion, and He will cure your depression.
John the Buddhist,-Lotus fan 卐卐
2012-03-28 00:14:57 UTC
live by a religion, dont die by it. if you must eat, eat. no good religion would say anything else.
2012-03-28 00:09:50 UTC
only a dumb *** would starve them self because of their religion


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...