Hegelian dialectic theory: a proof of God ?

Question

The central tenet of historical dialectic, is that all historical growth, change, and development results from the struggle of opposites. In philosophical terms, a thesis is opposed by its antithesis, which results in a synthesis. This struggle is the dialectic that drives the flywheel of history. It is so powerful, that the actions of individual men are of little consequence. Even though this view of history has been defended mostly by atheists, like Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Vladimir Ilich Lenin, and Joseph Stalin, is it not a remarkable proof that man is not the absolute master of his own fate ?. But who is it, then ?.

Answer 1

That's not anymore a proof of God than Dr. Pepper is a proof of that talking snake Eve chit chatted with.

Answer 2

The single Cell proofs the following statement it is the only sane answer that makes sense.



John 1



In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.

The same was in the beginning with God.



The Stumble bums of science so called fall all over the truth but deny the evidence.



Rom 1:20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:



Maranatha

Answer 3

because of the fact the theories save changing, and each and each time there's a sparkling concept, human beings say that's a info that God does not exist. the place did the situation and skill come from? The e book of Genesis isn't literal. It states the order of advent. The 7 days symbolises that factor is of no magnitude to God. in case you study the Bible, you could comprehend that. i've got self assurance in evolution and so on and could have self assurance interior the scientific comprehend-how of the international's advent while there is a few thing solid. it may be stupid to not, yet i don't think any began on that's very own. For some thing to start, it desires the measurement of time. With the measurement of time, the skill desires to have had a commencing up.

Answer 4

Not, in fact there is prof that there is no god and here it is in



SURVIVE 21:10 reads



ALL GODS MUST BE TESTED and if they fail they do not exist!



Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, there is zero or no evidence for the existence of god and there is zero or no evidence for the existence of the devil. They claim the power and ability of god and the devil is boundless, if this is true then a simple test to determine existence is in order.

This test will show either the gods/devils are not as powerful as claimed or they do not exist at all, in either case they do not deserve anyone's worship.



Here is a simple god/devil test

1. God you will post on every Forum, Blog, FAQ and Yahoo Answers Category on the internet in exactly 30 seconds (GMT) after this post has been made. You will post world wide and your post will state the following:



"I am god, I exist"



A) In every Forum, Blog, FAQ and Yahoo Answers Category must have the same exact time stamp based on human time GMT.



2. Mr. Devil you will post on every Forum, Blog, FAQ and Yahoo Answers Category on the internet in exactly 30 seconds (GMT) after this post has been made. You will post world wide and your post will state the following:



"I am devil, I exist"



A) In every Forum, Blog, FAQ and Yahoo Answers Category must have the same exact time stamp based on human time GMT.



This simple test shows the devil does not exist and god does not exist. Furthermore, there is nothing that states we can not test the devil or god for that mater.



The bible only states it's believers do not test god.



On the other hand there is nothing written anywhere that states we should not or can not test the devil so we tested both for completeness.



Note that since god and devil or two dependent if we show one does not exist then the other does not exist.



We have shown that gods of any kind exists; there is no god and no devil ;-)

Now happier times are a head for all people

Answer 5

If you have to construct such a convoluted theory that is based on a lot of false assumptions, then why even try? I thought "faith" was sufficient for you people.

Answer 6

I submit my life and my will to the Lord. That makes Him the Master of my destiny.



Col 2:8 Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ.

Answer 7

Philosophy shot straight out the *** of a cow.

Answer 8

i'm not smart enough for this :p i get you but don't have an answer.

Answer 9

No.