What does Islam teach about duty to your country ?

Question

Islam says you must respect the country where you live and earn

Why then Indian muslims

1- Help pakistan by bringing drugs and fake currency to India

2- why most of the gangsters extorting money and doing illegal work are muslims ?

3- why most of the crimes are done by muslims in India

4- Why Indian muslim dance with joy when India loses cricket to pakistan ?

5- why most of the Indian muslims are at heart against India, its laws and its culture ?

Answer 1

do you expect a logical reply ? they will report you like they are doing with me



My simple question - what is mantra for krishna worship" deleted saying insulting others



and anti hindu questions remain. Hindus are cowards and they deserve this. I am leaving YA, becuase I cant write for a coward race called Hindus, muslims are together and they report together and here muslim trolls like buddhafan, odumpully are openly insulting hinduism and no Hindu has guts to report and get them deleted ??



REAL SHAME ON HINDUS!!



BYE BYE FOR EVER

Answer 2

Muslim all over the world are muslim first and last the Quran is the law in any case if they are kuffair (nonbeliever) country they have to side by there Islamic brothers and sisters .It the same reason they don't integrate when they immigrate to a non muslim country



1- Help pakistan by bringing drugs and fake currency to India-agend defeat the kuffir by bleeding them with a thousand cut



2- why most of the gangsters extorting money and doing illegal work are muslims ? - for them Quran is law all othe laws are man made hence null and void.



3- why most of the crimes are done by muslims in India - they prefer to be isolated with seprate law and and islamic banking system which is not in India (lack of education)out of 17% less than 1% are educated in matric and UGC boards)



4- Why Indian muslim dance with joy when India loses cricket to pakistan ?- Allah has given victory over the kuffair team



5- why most of the Indian muslims are at heart against India, its laws and its culture ?- 80% is Kuffair

Answer 3

Duty of your country does not - does not prevent from any of above 5 points. Such offences are dealt as per law of the land.

Answer 4

because a lot of times muslims do not represent islam. That should be enough to answer your question

Answer 5

There is no relation to Islam and the people who you listed.

A muslim is not a muslim by having a muslim name.



1. False allegations and media hype. Bring proofs.

2. Not all of them are muslims. False allegations

3. Again false allegations. Remember Gujarat mulsim genocide. Greatest crime happened to muslims.

4. Not true, may be some black sheeps

5. False allegations.

Just by throwing some false allegations, your statement cannot become true and will not reach people.

Answer 6

@Shivam



I am very much concerned about those trolls and Anti Hindu questions. I have reported them, but most of the times even though after reporting they don't get deleted. I think Yahoo Answers is biased against us. And I urge other Hindus to take measures also. I think we need to fight together now against these trolls.

Answer 7

We muslims are for Islam not for India



and we will do what is good for Islam

Answer 8

Why India Hindus have been massacring Indian Muslims for last 60 years.

Let me answer your question



1. This is wrong accusation

2. It may be partially true. Simple reason all door for making money for muslim is closed. So, some of them took wrong path

3. Any statistics? If you are hindu, them now itself you committed a crime of deception.

4. Simply to make you hindus angry, because 60 years persistent massacres

5. It could be partially true and for the same reason above.



edit: Sivam, do you expect a logical answer for false accusation.

Answer 9

Shivam Ji, once you consoled Om ji when he showed the same problem and now you are urself leaving the Yahoo Answer.



This is not done. Hindus are not coward but a few of them are ignorant and people like you will definitely take them on right path.



Just don't go away and don't care for your account to be suspended or answer to be deleted..........just carry on.

Answer 10

Bro to get the people who have left islam or are ex muslims go to www.islam-watch.org to understand why they left Islam?

Answer 11

Brother ...your questions are illogical...

plz get your facts rite...it was the muslim Ulema of india which wer the very driving force for the first war indian independence...remember...1857 revolt...that was driven by the muslim Ulema...who laid down their lives...unfortunately we only here about Mangal Panday coz a movie was made on his life...and nuthing was mentioned about those hundreds and thousands of muslim soldiers who wer blown by britsh cannons....

Any proof on this plz that you may help me with...thr are equall no# of courrupt ppl in these crimes from other communities...Chota Rajan, Arun Gawli,Gopal Rajwani,Varadarajan Mudaliar,Sharad Sheety and the list gooos onn..you only here dawood ibrahim and abu salem etc....on TV and assume them to be muslim gangsters...all the way.....who in the world told you that most of the crimes done in india are done by muslims.....? pick up da news paper....no# rapes that happen ...they r not muslims who do this... there are no muslims who trade in liquor....we here about preachers from other religions who decive ppl for their money.......yes there are a few ignorant youth who enjoy pakis win over india.....but having said tht...you can not judge one's petriotism based on wht cricket team you support....thts ridiculous...and boy no muslim is against india at heart.....that can not happen co z we have our ansisters burried in this land its ours very much as it is yours...the fact is that muslims in India innumerable times have been asked to go to pakistan or other countries by a bunch of maniacs who feel they are petriotic indians....crapp. tht off. coz they only knw how to spread hate....its the muslims of india who brought the concept of bathroom to india.....else men and women in tis country didnt even knw that they need sumthing call as baathroom...india was ruled by muslim rulers for more than 500 yrs....your very existence is a proof that indian culture was allowed to grow and other religions wer being practiced...at those times...its the muslims in Gulf region who send all their earnings back to their home...in India...bringing in forign currency worth millions of dollars every month.....you dont seem to talk about that... dont you...just coz a bunch of polititions tell you all this crap you belive them ....brother learn to tolarate....and plz try to learn facts with an open mind....

God Bless you

Answer 12

I don't agree with u,,

don't be so biased,

first shaheed of kargil was a muslim,,

recently a muslim dharmguru let down musharraf on the issue of

muslims freedom in India.

whatever u have stated might be true,, but they r just 1% to muslim community in India.

by d way i'm a hindu.

Answer 13

Quran states that it is a duty upon a muslim to follow those in authority in their country.



Quote from the Prophet of Islam "Love for one's country is part of faith."





So also in the Hadith, the Holy Prophet (on whom be peace and the blessings of God) says:

"He who obeys me, obeys God; he who disobeys me disobeys God. He who obeys his authority obeys me; he who disobeys his authority disobeys me" (Muslim, Kitab al Imarah).



The founder of the Ahmadiyya muslim community, Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian, India said.



"The Holy Qur'an commands, 'Obey Allah and obey His Prophet and obey those in authority among you.' Believers are to obey those in authority, besides God and His Prophet. To say that 'those in authority' does not include a non-Muslin-Government would be a manifest error. For, a government-or authority-whose ordinances are in accordance with the Shariah (that is, they are not in conflict with it) is 'authority from among you.' Those who are not against us are among us. The Qur'an, therefore, is unequivocal on the point. Obedience to governmental authority is one of its imperatives." (Works and Speeches, Vol. (i), p. 261)



As for parts 1-5 of your question, I think these are unfair questions.

Answer 14

islam means i-Slam

end of discussion

Answer 15

Produce Proof, Do Not Blabber !



So, do you mean to say ALL Hindus are Angels - WTF !